Survivor: San Juan Del Sur- Blood vs. Water II

PUSH

Well-Known Member
Here's my rankings for the best players for this season:

1. Natalie - clearly the best of the season
2. Jeremy - could have been the best if he hadn't played it too hard in the beginning
3. Reed - could have been at the top had Keith not screwed up
4. Jon - the man behind several players' exits
5. Josh - give him more time and he could have done something big
6. Missy - did what she had to do to go far, just not appealing case to the jury
7. Jaclyn - I think she got the back end of the edit, was part of Jon's decisions, she just didn't match up physically
8. Keith - got far and was great in challenges, but he was also pretty clueless
9. Baylor - got far, but was carried most of the way
10. Wes - middle of the pack player, more a number than anything else
11. Dale - had a good thought process, but couldn't get the alliances aligned, plus he expressed his thoughts too much
12. Nadiya - I think she could have been Natalie if she wasn't voted out first
13. Alec - a number, became too unlikable early on
14. Val - was a fighter, but the alliances didn't line up
15. John Rocker - lost temper too easily, but was physically dominant, had no real chance at succeeding
16. Kelley - Who?
17. Drew - even more unlikable than Alec, and he was voted out quickly
18. Julie - strictly a number, no strategic mind, no physical ability, not strong (physically and mentally) enough to do much
 

DinoInstitute

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Advertisement
Here's my rankings for the best players for this season:

1. Natalie - clearly the best of the season
2. Jeremy - could have been the best if he hadn't played it too hard in the beginning
3. Reed - could have been at the top had Keith not screwed up
4. Jon - the man behind several players' exits
5. Josh - give him more time and he could have done something big
6. Missy - did what she had to do to go far, just not appealing case to the jury
7. Jaclyn - I think she got the back end of the edit, was part of Jon's decisions, she just didn't match up physically
8. Keith - got far and was great in challenges, but he was also pretty clueless
9. Baylor - got far, but was carried most of the way
10. Wes - middle of the pack player, more a number than anything else
11. Dale - had a good thought process, but couldn't get the alliances aligned, plus he expressed his thoughts too much
12. Nadiya - I think she could have been Natalie if she wasn't voted out first
13. Alec - a number, became too unlikable early on
14. Val - was a fighter, but the alliances didn't line up
15. John Rocker - lost temper too easily, but was physically dominant, had no real chance at succeeding
16. Kelley - Who?
17. Drew - even more unlikable than Alec, and he was voted out quickly
18. Julie - strictly a number, no strategic mind, no physical ability, not strong (physically and mentally) enough to do much
So, its been a little while since someone has posted on this thread, but I have finally gotten around to writting my own thoughts on these. A lot I agree with, the bolded I changed.

1. Natalie
2. Jeremy
3. Reed
4. Jon
5. Josh
6. Dale- He was a victim of circumstance IMO, sure he could have kept more quiet, but I think he made great moves and if he made the merge, could have taken it all the way to the end.
7. Missy
8. Jaclyn
9. Baylor - I switched her and Keith because I think she made a stronger effort in playing the game, although Keith was good in other aspects such as challenges
10. Keith-
11. Wes
12. Kelley - Moved her up because she had huge potential. Unfortunately, she was under-edited, but the few confessionals we got were very intelligent
13. Alec
14. Val
15. John Rocker
16. Nadiya - Moved her down because she really did not play her first day well. She could have survived
17. Drew
18. Julie
 
Top Bottom