Neat post and one that I've thought about before. In the past, I've posted about bringing a Smash Land to Universal Studios IOA area where Sinbad closed. Here is my idea for Smash Island:
1) Convert the old Sinbad show to a new live action Smash Bros stunt show. This would be a cool place to showcase several of the characters that would otherwise not get an attraction or any focus as far as a land. The show would feature a 'top of the line' light and sound package complete with special effects and abilities by the different characters. The seating area could be set up in sections where, depending on where you sit, will determine if you are the winner for that show. The main characters (Mario, Peach, Donkey Kong, Luigi) of the show would remain each time but the supporting characters could rotate a few times a day to keep the show fresh. Area would also host the lands main meet and greet section.
2) Replace Fire Eater's Grill with an Animal Crossing Themed experiences. Include a kid friendly area of the restaurant with interactive exhibits and kids sized play areas.
3) Re-skin Poseidon's Fury with a Zelda/Link themed attraction with Hyrule overlay. Incorporate some puzzles as part of the overaul experience.
4) Construct a new attraction (Rectangle box below) as a new trackless dark ride where you choose your avatar/character and then board a ride vehicle where you fight the characters from smash with the capabilities of your chosen character. This would be a shooter style attraction with seats that rumble and a top quality light and sound package. Perhaps you can unlock special character by doing certain things within the land such as: unlocking a puzzle at Zelda, choose winning section at Smash Show, up size your meal/buy a dessert at Animal Crossing, etc.. (Also considered a more thrilling Metroid themed shooting attraction with drops and spins but I think the Smash Dark ride would be more appealing and more family fiend to most guests).
5) Create a F-Zero hanging coaster. The Ride vehicle itself will be a larger hanging F-Zero vessel with buttons, levers, knobs, and a control dashboard. Build a dome around the attraction and allow the vehicle to have elements both inside and outside.. The inside will incorporate projection mapping to showcase the feeling of racing.
Thoughts?
View attachment 370346