News Star Wars: Galaxy's Edge - Historical Construction/Impressions

[SuddenStorm]

To be fair, I think nearly all fans just hated the character. Anyone who did give the actor himself a hard time is the worst kind of nerd.

This. I've seen tons and tons of Jar Jar and Rose jokes (who I assume @Evan-500 was referencing, I haven't really been following the thread the last day or two), but haven't seen anything that was directed towards the actor.

Part of participating in a film is opening yourself up to criticism of your performance, character, or the film itself. Every Jar Jar joke I've seen has been in good fun, and I've never seen anyone that said anything derogatory about the actor that portrayed him.

That said, I understand the negative toll on your mental health seeing a character you spent time portraying made fun of endlessly. I hope that as a fanbase, they also don't allow personal attacks on any of the actors in Star Wars.

 

[SWGalaxysEdge]

..>WOW things have gone wayyy off topic here.... Saw a RotR ride vehicle today and it has an ADA-complaint door.
The front "driver" side swings way open. Riders still need to xfer but it makes it easier to do so...

 

[SWGalaxysEdge]

New video from Jane

 

[Disney Irish]

..>WOW things have gone wayyy off topic here....

You've been here long enough, so should know. We tend to talk about all things (hopefully SW related) here.

 

[SuddenStorm]

I mean... fans have taken it out on the actors... Kelly Marie Tran quit social media because of it. As well, when you put a lot of effort and time into a character, it can be very damaging to have 1000s of people essentially bashing your work.

In the case of Tran, when she quit Instagram/social media- the overwhelming response online was "Racism and attacks on the actress herself within Star Wars fanbase in unnacceptable". Like Irish Bruh said, it gives people a voice who otherwise wouldn't have one and in some cases, probably shouldn't.

 

[Rich T]

..>WOW things have gone wayyy off topic here....

As usual, it's Jar Jar's fault.

 

[SuddenStorm]

Wow. That would be like me taking out my hate for GOTG:MB on Chris Pratt.

The comparison I'd use would be personally attacking Pressler and Harris vs attacking their professional decision making in regards to Disneyland. I think the fanbase unanimously dislikes what they did to Disneyland, but I don't think anyone would attack their appearance, race, or personal traits.

Which I hope is the case in Star Wars- I'd hope that any attack on Jar Jar/Rose wouldn't extend to the people that portrayed them.

 

[SuddenStorm]

As usual, it's Jar Jar's fault.

 

[Disney Irish]

Which I hope is the case in Star Wars- I'd hope that any attack on Jar Jar/Rose wouldn't extend to the people that portrayed them.

Unfortunately that is what happen. Too many fans took those characters as a personal slight and verbally attacked the actors directly on social media for "killing" their franchise.

 

[SuddenStorm]

Unfortunately that is what happen. Too many fans took those characters as a personal slight and verbally attacked the actors directly on social media for "killing" their franchise.

Perhaps I'm ignorant or just missed it... but I spent lots of time on Reddit in 2018 and never saw any attack on Tran herself, or any attacks on the guy that portrayed Jar Jar.

Not saying it didn't happen, since there's always people who feel the need to unnecessarily attack others, but I worry that it's an extremely small minority of people that should be disregarded and not taken seriously and give a bad name to all the other Star Wars fans.

 

[Disney Irish]

Perhaps I'm ignorant or just missed it... but I spent lots of time on Reddit in 2018 and never saw any attack on Tran herself, or any attacks on the guy that portrayed Jar Jar.

Not saying it didn't happen, since there's always people who feel the need to unnecessarily attack others, but I worry that it's an extremely small minority of people that should be disregarded and not taken seriously and give a bad name to all the other Star Wars fans.

Even a small minority that uses race to attack is one too many.

 

[SuddenStorm]

Even a small minority that uses race to attack is one too many.

I agree, but I worry that the story has been portrayed in such a way to make it sound like the Star Wats community has a meaningful portion of people who resort to such attacks.

 

[Disney Irish]

I agree, but I worry that the story has been portrayed in such a way to make it sound like the Star Wats community has a meaningful portion of people who resort to such attacks.

Well that same can be said about a lot of things in life, or any fandom for that matter. The vocal minority is what gets covered by the media no matter the topic. Its unfortunate but the old saying is true, "The squeaky wheel gets the grease", meaning the loudest and most vocal gets the most attention.

 

[bclane]

I agree, but I worry that the story has been portrayed in such a way to make it sound like the Star Wats community has a meaningful portion of people who resort to such attacks.

It's definitely not the majority of the Star Wars fanbase that is attacking the actors themselves imo, but there was a considerable amount of hate poured on on Tran, Best, Lloyd, etc. It's truly a shame that people can be so hateful.

 

[SWGalaxysEdge]

You've been here long enough, so should know. We tend to talk about all things (hopefully SW related) here.

...I just want a little slack then, when I talk about the WDW version sometimes.
At least I am still talking SWGE.

 

[flynnibus]

That's exactly what I'm thinking too. None of this stuff is worth my money, it all just seems a tad too vague and nerdy looking. I wouldn't display it anywhere, or want to look at it.

Most of it looks like the resin cast crap they had in the fake prop area at DHS. You can be nerdy if its impressive or real looking.. fake and nerdy... no bueno.

 

[Rich T]

It's definitely not the majority of the Star Wars fanbase that is attacking the actors themselves imo, but there was a considerable amount of hate poured on on Tran, Best, Lloyd, etc. It's truly a shame that people can be so hateful.

That's the dark side of fandom, whether it be films, comics, sports, video games or theme parks. Some people lose all perspective (or never had any to begin with). It's sad.

 

[socalifornian]

That's the dark side of fandom, whether it be films, comics, sports, video games or theme parks. Some people lose all perspective (or never had any to begin with). It's sad.

 

[bclane]

That's the dark side of fandom, whether it be films, comics, sports, video games or theme parks. Some people lose all perspective (or never had any to begin with). It's sad.

True. I really hope I never succumb to the Dark Side (although they do have cookies ).

 

[Disney Irish]

...I just want a little slack then, when I talk about the WDW version sometimes.
At least I am still talking SWGE.

Nope no slack, since there is a subforum specifically for discussions on DHS and their smaller SW:GE version.

I can't help it if we're more interesting over here....