Stayed at the AKL in December and the pool stayed open fairly late. The bar closed but the pool deck and bar seating area were still open (my son and I played Monopoly at one of the tables) and no one chased us off.
However, we just returned from another AKL stay this past weekend (end of January) and the pool closed promptly at 9pm (or was it 8pm!?). We had just sat down on the lounge chairs, drinks from the bar in hand at quarter 'til the hour (EDIT: just the wife and I this time, no kids
), and an attendant proceeded to curtly plop down a large POOL CLOSED sign right in front of where we were sitting! Nice.
The bar shut down moments later, and while we had already moved on, another guest who was there at the same time, told us a few minutes later that security actually told her "You have to leave NOW."
Not sure if it's a new policy or an early close due to cold weather.
I can understand closing the pool itself when lifeguards are off duty, but forcing responsibly-behaved guests to leave the deck area entirely seems quite extreme, considering the prices charged and promise of a "deluxe" experience. The policy needs to be enforced with a bit of common sense. No need to chase off guests who are just trying to relax. Let grownups be grownups for goodness sake.
P.S. No ridiculous (yes, I said it) fence around the pool area yet, FWIW. Really hoping they don't go that route as it would seriously hinder the exotic feel of the resort.