I've only been to the Grotto at the Polynesian. I'm a bit of a tiki snob and was a little disappointed. It's still much better than most out there but missing something???
I'm looking forward to a few days in Anaheim this October. I'm planning on making Trader Sams my daily escape or two or three.
How are the early crowds on weekdays? From open until 3 or 4?
They're both pretty cool and hold their own IMO with unique touches. Florida's isn't really all that much bigger. They do have the added plus of outdoor seating on the water, but, much like ours in Disneyland -- if you're outside, you're not really going to get the Trader Sam's experience.
To me, what ultimately makes the Disneyland location win is its hours of operation. WDW's doesn't open until 4! I love hitting TS's for a mid-day drink and appetizer or two before the crazy crowds descend. Can't do that in Florida sadly.
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.