I think SW would win even on a Nintendo fansite. The force is nowhere stronger than amongst Gamers.
As for me, I love games, but unless somebody opens Civilisation Land it is not even a contest. And even if that would give me the opportunity to pretend to be All Mighty Global Overlord, what is the difference with pretending to be just that when playing a game? That, I think, is one flaw of the 'interactive' fad. Imagine a screen based Mario attraction that allows you to control the movement of what happens on the screen simply by swiping your magicband. It is a great evolution of the old static ride...into something found in your home. The theme park full circle, from bringing to life that which the guest sees on the flat 2D screen into a real environment, to bringing this environment into an interactive, user-driver, screen-based environment to fulfill individual desires, so the guest can see just what he sees on the flat 2D screen at home.