Orlpassholder, I was waiting for you to chime in on this one. Some of us are even more than a little "off.:. LOL I have even seen people go as far as dressing up Mickey with all sorts of pins on his jacket, but this does not make them odd. LOL
Anyway, my wife and I really enjoy the pin trading. We are probably a little more than $700 into the hobby. We enjoy finding the pins.
What we do is usually buy pins at a big discount from our local Disney store here in town. We take down a bunch of pins to trade with while we are there. We usually have quests to complete. We of course try to collect the lanyard pins, we also try to get pins that are from things we like. (attractions, hotels, characters from movies, etc.).
So, we really shape our collection based on what we "find". We start off with 200 pins that are all the same and at the end of our trip, we have a montage of things that we have assembled over a week or so. It is lots of fun. The only pins we usually buy are the ones that seem extra special, or are unique and we can use them to trade with others for pins we may not be able to "happen upon" during our journeys. It really gives us even more to remember our trip with as each pin has its own story behind it.
We have also met some really great people throguh pin trading, CM's, board posters, etc. As long as you go into it as a hobby and realize it is expensive, it is really enjoyable. I certainly enjoy having pins to look at to remember our trips by rather than a thimble or spoon on the wall.
My view with Orlpassholders gives you $.04 worth of thought!
Dizneykev