Peter Pan's Flight vs The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

[Chip Chipperson]

I voted for Winnie the Pooh. Peter Pan is fine, but I enjoy Pooh more. I like the bouncing Tigger section, the freaky acid trip section, and the thunder storm sections of the ride much more than anything on Peter Pan.

 

[Goofyernmost]

I also like flying over London.

A negative for Winnie is no more Mr. Toad.

I know a lot of people loved the Toad, but to me it was the cheapest attraction that Disney (especially Walt) was ever involved with. It was an off the shelf roadside carnival dark ride with painted scenes and a weaving track. I have never missed it. When I went of Disneyland's 50th I decided to ride it again just to see if I was forgetting what it was like. I wasn't, I still didn't like it.

 

[larryz]

I am nominating Peter Pan's Flight as "The Ride Most Likely To Be Changed Next."

Bye-bye, Original American village...

 

[Kingoglow]

Pooh is just poorly imagineered. We never go on Pooh because every thing is so cheap.

 

[TotallyBiased]

Ridden Pooh once and that was enough. Wife and I both felt the ride outpaced the story and the audio was too low, and just felt "meh.". Wasn't impressed with it whatsoever. I loved Winnie the Pooh as a kid. I was disappointed.

Pan, while there's a nostalgic component, the simple effects are just fun. The updated queue makes the wait much nicer as well.

 

[Centauri Space Station]

Pooh is just poorly imagineered. We never go on Pooh because every thing is so cheap.

Cheaper than toad which was all flat cardboard?

 

[jloucks]

For me, once you strip away the nostalgia of Pan, I don't think it's a great attraction - E.T at USF does the same concept but better.

I enjoy the Pooh ride - particularly the Tiger 'Acid Nightmare' section.

I agree E.T. for the solid win, but Pan is a respectable contender.

I also like the Pooh ride. It is not as sophisticated as the others, but still pleasurable. (I don't get the hate)

 

[erasure fan1]

Pan was my vote because of the ride system. Both rides are pretty close to each other from a quality standpoint. But the ride system gives Pan the edge for me. I do wish that Disney would update the AAs and special effects a bit. But unfortunately all Disney sees is a nice fat line, so no need to do anything.

 

[fireworksandfairytales]

I chose The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh. I can acknowledge that Peter Pan's Flight is a "better" ride, but Pooh was a must on all of my childhood trips and I still love bouncing with Tigger and seeing the Heffalumps and Woozles!

 

[LittleMerman]

I love Pooh but I voted for Peter Pan bc of the ride system and the quality of the ride seems better.

 

[Aussiejen79]

Im voting for Peter Pan as its my favourite ride.....i try to ride it first up at Rope drop

 

[Dayma]

Both are on our "must ride" lists but if I had to pick one if would be Peter Pan's Flight, mostly because I grew up with it. Cant go wrong with either.

 

[S.I.R. the Robot]

Pooh was my childhood. I rode it TWICE at age 6, because I loved it so much, I wanted to go on again! Too bad when I re-rode it at 13, I was completely OUT OF IT, due to a lack of sleep the night before. I had to be reciting Game Grumps in order not to have an OBE.