TikiBeckie,
I am not sure how old you and your boyfriend are, but I am 20 and my boyfriend is 22 and we have stayed at Old Key West, Boardwalk Villas and Villas at Wilderness Lodge.
My parents LOVE OKW and swear by it, they love driving up their room and walking right to it. We usually stay in a 2 bedroom there, although the one time we got a Grand Villa that was amazing. It's very pretty, but being from South Florida the tropical appeal isn't very different.
My (and my boyfriends') absolute favorite was BW, by far. I LOVE the atmosphere, I LOVE having to walk through the lobby and enjoy the full flair of the hotel. I love sitting on the balcony (we get boardwalk views, a couple extra points and if you are paying cash, I'm sure a couple extra bucks) over the boardwalk, eating our dessert from the bakery and enjoying the sights and sounds. Another plus of course, IS the bakery and restaurants..something to do when it's too late to go to the parks and you've already done Pleasure Island...grab some cookies or ice cream and hang around. The rooms are a little smaller, but two people don't really need much room. I also like having valet (free for DVC members) and bellhop service..
Villas were also nice, but I felt a little secluded from the rest of the resort, you weren't forced to walk through the lobby from the busstop really..so it took away from my kind of atmosphere.
Anymore questions, feel free to ask!:wave: