Thank you for this exactly! I was lucky to hear about this Fathom event actually happening on my day off (often I hear about it after, or it's playing a night I work) so I was more than happy to see Newsies this way- and I loved it! The music and the choreography were amazing, just fantastic!
Not to mention, the theater I saw it at here in Jensen Beach was PACKED, way more than I've seen for a regular movie in this area for awhile.
It was GREAT! This was the only way I was going to be able to see this particular Broadway show- and I was glad of it. I even looked up Jeremy Jordan online after the show, to see what else he is doing, because that guy is a talent!
As for the detractor, I can't imagine being "annoyed" that people who don't have the time, money or opportunity to schep all the way to NYC get to be exposed to and enjoy the entertainment of Broadway on a big screen. It's not a zero sum game, so it takes nothing away from those who do go to NY.
I don't even want to ask why it's okay for PBS on a small screen, but not a big screen? That makes no sense.