We have both the Disney Visa and the Disney Debit Card. We almost solely use the Debit Card now.
Sure, the CC gets 1% instead of .5%, but we've tried to stop using the CC to help the 'ol credit score. Also, we want to avoid the upcoming outrageous interest rates that CC companies are starting to slap on. Besides, using Debit instead of Credit saves another step (i.e. money comes out right now, and no CC bill to pay).
The $25 is waived the first year, once you make a few qualifying purchases. We have already hit the $25 cash-back level anyway, in just a few months. We use it to pay any bills that accept credit card, which REALLY adds up quickly.
We like it. We're confident that we'll hit our $25 fee early in 2010 and rack up some easy spending money for our 2011 trip.