My 2 cents worth after eating my way thru WDW more times than I will admit to.
Best Overall: Citrico's. Great food/wine/atmosphere/service. Ask for Tom regarding wine selections. Elegant restaurant but you don't have to dress to the nine's. Food is wonderful and the attentiveness and concern by the staff is unparalled.
Flying Fish - Casual, fantastic food. Must have - Chocolate Lava Cake for dessert. My second favorite restaurant at WDW.
Boma - AKL. Best buffet I have ever had! Creative foods, best soups ever, great use of spices, noisy, definitely need a PS! Desserts (Zebra Dome) are amazing!
Jiko's - Try the tenderloin with macaroni and cheese! Wierd combo, but great as is the sauce. Wonderful atmosphere. High end dining experience in a gorgeous restaurant.
Pepper Market - Casual, very good, nice food selection.
Kona Cafe - Used to be the Coral Isle at the Poly. Really good food and service. Exotic desserts! Great place to eat.
Artists Point - Another of the 'don't miss' restaurants. The planked salmon is extraordinary! Very nice selection of NW American wines.
Yachtsman's Steakhouse - Expensive but good food and service. The portions aren't very big if you have a huge appetite.
Maya Grill - Very underated. Quiet and very nice food. Kind of
creative-Americanized- Mexican. Super Margarita's!!!
Victoria & Alberts - The epitome of dining! Coat & tie, subdued atmosphere and everything you expect from a 5 star restaurant. Personalized menu's, rose for the ladies, and absolutely perfect service to accompany an extraordinary meal in an elegant dining room.
Prime Time Cafe - Big improvement in food in the past year. Fun place to go!
Brown Derbv - Excellent food. Atmosphere very relaxing. Nice wine list.
Sci-Fi - Forget it. Atmosphere fun, food expensive and not very good
Bistro de France (the one upstairs) - Excellent food and service with a nicer atmosphere than the Chefs de France downstairs. Quieter too.
Coral Reef - Great atmosphere looking at all of the fish! Food is just so-so and is quite expensive.
LeCellier - Probably the best food in Epcot. Atmosphere is just OK, but their stuffed steak and cheese soup can't be beat.
California Grill - Overrated (sorry). Atmosphere is the best but the food, though creative, can be warmed over and dry with small portions. Service is rushed and restaurant is loud and noisy.
Downtown Disney: Fultons - Avoid!! Super expensive and just not worth the $$$. Pushy servers, mediocre food. A tragedy compared to what the Empress Lily was.
Bongo's - Average
Wolfgang Pucks - long waits, good food, crowded all of the time. Good place for sushi.
Captain Jack's - great Margarita's and Daiquiri's!!! Food is pretty good too!
Citrico's