Narcoossee’s or Paddlefish?

[Editor516]

Simple enough... which is better and more worth the 2 dining credits?

 

[networkpro]

Narcoosee's

 

[DisAl]

I have never been to Paddlefish, but when we were there last March for our 45th anniversary trip Narcoossee's was the best of five signature restaurants we did. The butter poached lobster tails were excellent!

 

[Chi84]

We’ve been to Paddlefish twice and were not impressed with the food or service. We prefer the Boathouse or STK in Disney Springs. Trying Narcoossee’s for the first time in a few months.

 

[surfsupdon]

Been to both.

Narcoossee’s easily, for better service, better food, and a great experience.

Paddlefish had good food, but Narc’s was better.

 

[sgtmgd]

Narcoossee's Very good food and a great view.

 

[sdemore]

We are going for 2 weeks in December, at my DH's request we have 3 ADR's for Narcoosee's and 1 ADR for Paddlefish. I think that tells you our choice as to which we think is better.

 

[jim1051]

If I am using 2 credits, it better have ambience, service and great food. Add my vote to Narcoosees for all three

 

[westie]

I liked PF but it was a bit loud.

 

[GSP Guy]

Narcoossee's! It would be impossible to drag me back into Paddlefish!

 

[ABZDisneyFan]

We've eaten in both place & Narcoossee's is way nicer, for food, service & view.