Yeah, it's that ugly combination of a half-baked story, message, and characters, poor execution of such (i.e. the songs),
and that this was the centennial project, "A Story 100 Years in the Making" that was explicitly advertised as in the great tradition of films like
Beauty and the Beast , and that (
as far as we know) didn't undergo the miserablly meddled-with production that films like
The Emperor's New Groove,
Frozen II, etc. did that made people so unhappy with
Wish, and why I don't think it would have done any better this year than it did last (imagine
Wish going up against
Wicked Part One!).
But bringing this back to
Moana 2, as successful as it's been financially it's clear the critical response is getting to some people, as seen in this puff piece interview:
'Moana 2' songwriters Abigail Barlow and Emily Bear discuss writing new songs for the heroine's next island adventure and criticism from audiences.
variety.com