We're going in May 2014, too! It will be 3 generations going together, aged 5-72, so there are many different tastes to accommodate. That being said, after distributing a dining survey and gauging everyone's interest in the various restaurants (yes, I really made a 4-page written survey and my family members gamely filled it out!) here's what we decided on for our table-service meals, in order to get a "well-rounded" food experience that incorporates different types of meals (e.g., some buffets, some character meals, some international cuisines, etc.). The ADR line-up (if we can get them, otherwise I revert to the "runners-up") we chose -- and which I hope will give the OP some ideas -- is as follows:
- Day 1 - Dinner at Liberty Tree Tavern (MK, all-you-can eat Colonial American Thanksgiving fare)
(*Runner-up: Crystal Palace, MK, American buffet with Pooh characters)
- Day 2 - Dinner at Cinderella's Royal Table (MK, Fancy-ish menu, Princess Character meal)
(*We would have preferred Be Our Guest, but our daughter's birthday will fall on day 2 of our trip and we
allowed her to choose the dinner venue. We felt that two "castle" dinners with "Disney upscale" menus
would be a little redundant, so we'll have lunch at BOG one day instead.)
- Day 3 - Lunch or "milkshake stop" at the Sci-Fi Dine-in Theater (HS, old-timey drive-in movie theme)
Dinner show: Hoop-de-doo Musical Revue (FW, All-you-can-eat Western BBQ with slapstick comedy show)
(*Runner-up: Artist Point, a signature American Northwest restaurant at Wilderness Lodge)
- Day 4 - Dinner at the Coral Reef (Epcot, seafood restaurant with glass wall facing into aquarium)
(*Runners-up: The Garden Grill, Epcot, American all-you-can-eat restaurant rotates to show Living with
the Land scenery, and Via Napoli, Epcot, wood-fired pizzas and Italian specialties)
- Day 5 - Dinner at the Biergarten (Epcot, all-you-can-eat German buffet with live polka band)
(*Runners-up: Restaurant Marrakesh, Moroccan restaurant, and Chefs de France, French braisserie)
- Day 6 - Dinner at 'Ohana (Polynesian Resort, all-you-can-eat skewer meats, etc.)
(*Runners-up: Kona Cafe, quieter, more upscale Polynesian-inspired offerings at the PR, or California Grill
at the Contemporary Resort, a signature restaurant)