We returned Oct. 1st after 12 days in the World, and I'm glad I wasn't alone in my feelings of shock at the mobs of people during what we had read to be one of the "slowest" (relatively) times in the parks. Not helping was what seemed like "August weather" (heat, humidity, afternoon rain) that decided to hang on through the end of September. We were at MNNSHP on the 21st and were quite surprised at the near-gridlock at this hard-ticketed event. We had fun, but what we found that getting on major attractions was easy; meeting characters and trick-or-treating was near-impossible.
Whenever our next trip will be, it'll be no earlier than October, or maybe even later - maybe squeezed in between the end of MNSSHP and the Thanksgiving crowds.
Trip highlights: Concierge level at Beach Club - our choice, not an upgrade. Did this 5 years ago, found this much improved, great CM's, and being able to breakfast in the lounge covcered half of the upcharge. (We weren't on the dining plan.) Wild Africa Trek - wonderful. Lunch With an Imagineer at Brown Derby - teriffic. Sunrise Safari at AKL - good time. Great meals at Tony's (A sentimewntal favorite); Boma; California Grill; House of Blues in Downtown Disney; Brown Derby (lunch and dinner). Even Crystal Palace (despite the noise). We chose not to be on the Dining Plan until the last couple of days of our trip, when we moved to AKL.
Not quite so great: Jiko (posted a comment in another thread) -- nothing like the menu, service, and knowledgable CM as we experienced on our last visit. Club Level at AKL: food was good, but very inconvenient distance from our room; Flying Fish - meh. Agree with merchandise comments we read prior to our trip: poor quality on many things, bad designs, hard to find something we wanted, same stuff everywhere, wish the characters hadn't invaded all the pin designs, wish there whad been some nice resort logo merch and not DVC logo items everywhere instead.
Several ride interruptions on Splash, one on Pirates, but otherwise no problems.
They need to design a new pin: I Survived the Attack of the Triple-Wide Strollers.