I'd have to see him in a movie that wasn't directed by Zach Snyder before I'd even consider the question. The man does not understand the DC universe characters so he is incapable of making a good movie with those characters. Not that he is a particularly good director to begin with.
I didn't mind him, but he isn't better than Bale. I watched the extended cut (never saw in theatres because of reviews) and enjoyed it quite a bit. People might get angry about this, but I liked it better than Ultron.