A few people have mentioned that they don't think the DDP is worth it. I've spoken to my Dad who insists I'm wrong. He really wants to do it, so who am I to argue? I'm just happy to be going period!
Use this calculator... to see if its worth it. http://www.distripplanner.com/
When I go I am doing a lot of Character Meals and TS meals too since it is my Daughters first trip. And I put in Ever Place I planned on eating, (Days I am not sure I just guess which QS Meal I would prob get.) It comes out Cheaper for me to just pay OOP. I think it estimated me at Saving only $90. But In reality I will save much more than that since my family all orders Water for our meals (Wife and daughter will get Juice/Milk in the morning, but that is it) Also my wife mentioned that she was looking at some menus and prob would be happy with just getting an appetizer for some meals, or a small salad. So in the end it would save me even more money. (Plus I don't think we each need a desert at every meal).
You also mentioned having some pickier eaters... I am guessing that means more Pizza/Chicken/Pasta meals which are cheaper than your higher end Steaks/Seafood Meals. Either way I will try to give you an update next week after I book all of my reservations...
This is what I am going for incase you are wondering...
Whispering Canyon Cafe, 1900 Park Fare, Coral Reef, Tusker House, Rainforest Cafe, Boma, O'hana, Hoop-De-Doo Review, Hollywood & Vine, 50's Prime Time Cafe, Chef Mickey's, The Crystal Palace, Be Our Guest, Akershus Royal Banquet Hall, T-Rex, Cinderellas Royal Table, Skipper Canteen, Garden Grill (YES... 18 sit down meals in 10 days LOL)
My ADR window opened this week, and I had a lot of similar reservations as you. Here's what I found:
Mama Melrose: This filled up the FASTEST, especially considering that the reservations aren't at optimal dining times. The best I could do for Mama Melrose/Fantasmic package was 2:10pm - so lunch. I booked a reservation for Hollywood & Vine's Fantasmic package as well, and got a 5pm reservation. I figure I'll cancel one as we get closer.
San Angel Inn: No problem getting these reservations mid-trip. We're a group of 4, also
Be Our Guest: We got reservations for lunch instead of dinner, but did it for our last day of the trip and had no problem getting ideal reservations.
We also looked into Le Cellier, and those reservations were wide open, too.
Hope this helps!
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.