It depends on what deals are taking place at the time. Our next trip is AoA just because I really really wanted to stay there! I do have a love for the overly themed value resorts since I have a 5 yo son. Originally I had booked us two Little Mermaid rooms. However, the room discount came out and it was about the same price for us to have a Cars Suite and we could all be together. Also, the suites are closer to the main building for my Mom who has a foot issue. I was totally excited to have a suite for a cheaper price.
I do have a love for the Lodges... If a room discount comes out and there are only 4 of us going it would be AKL or WL for us! I know it is nice to be near the parks like Contemporary or Poly but for me its not always worth it. We have tried many resorts; yacht club, dolphin, CBR, all values except AoA, CSR, PORQ, SSR. But none of those hold up to the lodges in my mind. If the price is right...you will know where to find me!