First, I'm a bit amazed at how much people will defend Disney, no matter what. However, the people pointing out that their contingency plan is just that, are correct. They need to state what they will do in the event of a downturn in the economy. One of those things is their traditional method of using APers as "filler". It's what they do.
What these defenders miss, however, is the "love and devotion to Disney" from those who'd likely buy an AP. These folks fill VERY tied to a Disney community and to Disney, specifically. This has been bred over their lifetimes from watching Wonderful World of Disney or Disney Channel on TV to now. Everything is "magical" to them. As such, it's a bit off-putting to have the CEO of Disney describe you as "undesirable" (or whatever word he used - it wasn't flattering) and have them play games with you like, "Sure you can have an AP with no black-out dates but not ALL dates will be available for a reservation because that's an entirely separate issue. Also, give us your money!" only to find out they want you to buy their APs now and get you in the parks to boost numbers but know that, as soon as the numbers start rising again, they'll go back to the old ways of encouraging to renew your AP but maybe not come as often (they still want your money, after all).
For those of you who grew up in the Church of Disney. Your god doesn't care about you. He wants your money but will take others over you if they'll pay more. That's the way this works.
We've discussed, several times on this forum, how APers are "filler". Why this is a sudden surprise to people blows my mind. You're "filler" like it or not, that's what you are and all you'll ever be as an APer. I'm not saying it's bad nor good. It is what it is.
Internally they have a word like, "Annual Assholders," or something along those lines. That's where you stand.
The interesting take is that if you're an APer for any other operation, they appear to appreciate you. I think Dollywood does this best. They're happy to have loyal customers. Disney, however, has enough loyal customers that they aren't happy about it but more annoyed that they have to deal with it (unless they need filler). Generally speaking, they don't want you because they have a ton of people lined up screaming, "I LOVE DISNEY! TAKE MY MONEY!".
I'll add: It sucks that this is where we're at.