I guess I should restate my opinion. It's not that I did not like Paradise Pier. It is a fine hotel in of itself. But it's not what I have come to expect from a Disney hotel when paying $200+ a night. To put it in perspective, our favorite hotel on WDW property is the Wilderness Lodge, which we've paid anywhere between $185-$245/night for depending on what specials are running and what time of year we've stayed. At that price point, you get overrun with themeing, amenities, etc. Staying at Paradise Pier for the higher end of that WL price point, I felt like we got much less "Disney", I know that lodging in SoCal is more expensive in general, but our room was smaller (King room so only one bed and small pullout couch), no balcony, very modestly themed, no themed pool, etc. I just know that I we could have paid half the price for a much closer hotel that included more amenities. Sure it might not have been a "Disney" hotel, but PP just didn't feel like one either. If we were willing to spend the extra 25% on top of the PP pricing, we would just stay at the Disneyland Hotel this time around, but this was a last minute trip that we booked in the beginning of December and we weren't looking to go overboard with it.