During our last trip, Garden Grill was probably our favorite meal. The food was good, the character interaction was fantastic, and the service was great. We had heard mixed reviews, but we were very pleasantly surprised at how much we enjoyed it. The food isn't gourmet, but it was well-prepared and fresh. I especially enjoyed the turkey, stuffing, and the sweet potato fries from the kids' menu.
Had both within the last year and thought both were great. I would go back to either of them again.
Read reviews that Coral Reef had a bad rep but I was pleasantly surprised. Garden Grill was a favorite also. Really liked the family style setup, getting to choose which items you wanted more of was great.
@OswaldTheRabbit I have been to the cr a few times. It is a great atmosphere. The food is alright and I love practically any kind of seafood. It is something I would suggest someone to do at least once. Have fun trying to decide!!!!