My first visit with my family, way back when Disney did provide a real magical experience (1996 ish), They had an add on to the package called the Silver Plan (I think that was what it was called). It was a very inexpensive add on which had almost no limitations, had recreation benefits and covered all TS restaurants and the Luau plus tips. My kids were mostly young and my oldest was young at heart. Lots of character meals, had breakfast at CRT, and did the Luau.
That was a heck of a deal. Now, I wouldn't touch any dining plan with a 10' pole. They don't work for me now.
I miss the old days.