More than meets the eye
Well, griz, you will be happy to know that I also like the show, partly for sentimental reasons like others, but also because it is truly authentic in some special ways. I only think that it would be a good idea to "digitally remaster" its soundtrack and reprogram the bears so that it will not sound and run as poorly as it has recently (last year).
On the sentimental side, I am 36 and remember going to it with my parents growing up. They loved country music and camping, and so it was a natural. But as I have grown up, I have found more reasons to appreciate it.
First, the park needs non-thrill rides that appeal to older audiences, and to rural tastes. That used to be WDW's greatest appeal: that it had something for everyone. It's nice to have something to share with "grandma," and I mean that. Especially older visitors from the South and mid-west may enjoy this.
Second, I am a fan and somewhat a historian of country music, and the voices on this show are true classics that really captured a style of vaudeville-meets-the-mountains that really existed in the early part of this century. Even the red-curtain staging and show style does a good job of "teaching" kids about an era that is mostly gone by. It actually follows the real style of the early Grand Ole Opry and other "barn dances" of the period, while having fun with them.
The voice list includes true country pioneers, such as Kitty Wells and Tex Ritter (John Ritter's father). As with most things that Disney did in the early park planning days, the research was real and the "extras" were there for authenticity sake. [For some more fun trivia, spend time looking into the other recorded voices around the park."]
The only thing that I suggest is that the equipment be overhauled and the soundtrack restored digitally for better sound. And I really wouldn't mind a new show recording itself with some newer, yet traditional country stars on occasion. (Walt himself wanted things never to be completed, but constantly revised.) I would like it preserved, however, for those reasons.