This is a tough one... Say, 15 years ago, my husband and I would book a 7 day at Caribbean Beach with park hoppers. The parks were open later and we didn't get upcharged for every little thing. A few years later, we stayed at Pop Century-room only, and would get a few days of tickets from Undercover Tourist. During this period, they decided to bring out "Free Dining" (haha) and the price of food got stupid, so we would make sure to bring a bunch of our own or eat offsite. Last year we sprung for 13 month AP's with the hope of going at least 3 times during that period, but now looking at the All Star hotels-room only. As it gets increasingly more expensive, we have to downsize to cheaper hotels or stay offsite to stay in the same budget. (We don't get raises each year). We are still hoping to go in January before the AP's expire, as we won't be renewing them, but am waiting to see what deals come out before then.
We know that this is the last hurrah for us at Disney, and no, we don't think it's worth the cost any longer.