character costumes

cruiseman

New Member
Original Poster
Ya im really surprised too. I hope that disney security really looks into this dude. He looks like hes trying to make some really fast cash, especially with no sales on ebay before, thats one hell of a first sale.
 

cymbaldiva

Active Member
Ya'll! Color me blonde but I just don't get it!

Why would the costumes be worth soooo much? I'm thinking (could be wrong though :) ) that John Stamos paid less than that for the original Disneyland sign..

I could be mistaken though ....that special was on very early in the morning! :lol:
 
Im guessing the reason the price is so high is...there is nothing like this anywhere else in the world really.

If someone bid this, and won it...and got to keep it...legally...which I doubt they would, they would be one of the only people in the world with these items.

That is a money maker right there.


I CAN NOT believe that this is really being auctioned, I promise Disney is all over it already.



Jordan
 

Yellow Shoes

Well-Known Member
Why would the costumes be worth soooo much?

These costumes, like the antiques on "Antiques Roadshow", or most of the items for sale on Ebay, are worth what someone will pay for them.

If this guy can get $50K, then that's what they're worth.

I think everyone here is hoping they're worth a trip to prison!
 
These are most likely stolen, but it is interesting that they were created in 1982. That's not the same Donald Duck costume they are using now. I wouldn't think Disney would keep these around if they were "discontinued" costumes. Anyone know about anything about this?
 

mkt

When a paradise is lost go straight to Disney™
Premium Member
sigh... I just reported this one again to WDW security
 

Worldphile

New Member
Originally posted by Yellow Shoes


These costumes, like the antiques on "Antiques Roadshow", or most of the items for sale on Ebay, are worth what someone will pay for them.

If this guy can get $50K, then that's what they're worth.

I think everyone here is hoping they're worth a trip to prison!


*shrugs*

No one is going to prison over this, IMHO. Even if the costumes were stolen, and reported as such ot the Orange County Sheriff's Dept., what is the statute of limitations on theft in Florida?

Disney may have a claim to get their property back, but if that stuff is insured, and they made a claim which was paid by the insurer, then I think the costumes would techincally belong to the insurer. Or they just may be considered lost property after all this time.

But after 15-20 years, I'm not sure there is much that Disney can do criminally.

As for selling a Disney character item without paying royalties to Disney though..... :drevil:
 

mkt

When a paradise is lost go straight to Disney™
Premium Member
Originally posted by Worldphile
No one is going to prison over this, IMHO. Even if the costumes were stolen, and reported as such ot the Orange County Sheriff's Dept., what is the statute of limitations on theft in Florida?


They were stolen... there's no other way to get them off property. Being that they were stolen from private property located within a privately-run legal jurisdiction, I am not sure what it specifically is. Also, since Disney conducts its own private investigations, I believe they will get something

Originally posted by Worldphile
Disney may have a claim to get their property back, but if that stuff is insured, and they made a claim which was paid by the insurer, then I think the costumes would techincally belong to the insurer. Or they just may be considered lost property after all this time.

I don't know what the insurance is on something that they made... ex- can you insure a car that you personally manufactured. I doubt they insure the costumes.


Originally posted by Worldphile
But after 15-20 years, I'm not sure there is much that Disney can do criminally.

there's always civil court..
 

cymbaldiva

Active Member
mktiggerman -

You know I agree with you just about all the time...but civil court?

That's for money damages...what court on the planet is going to award $$ damage to Disney?

Call me a pesimist if you will, but I really don't think so :)
 

bearboysnc

Well-Known Member
Originally posted by Worldphile



*shrugs*

No one is going to prison over this, IMHO. Even if the costumes were stolen, and reported as such ot the Orange County Sheriff's Dept., what is the statute of limitations on theft in Florida?

Wow, you don't go to jail for burglery in FL?

It must be all those damn liberals in Dade County.
 

mkt

When a paradise is lost go straight to Disney™
Premium Member
Originally posted by cymbaldiva
That's for money damages...what court on the planet is going to award $$ damage to Disney?

look at Disney's record when they go to court. They have only lost 4% of any case that they have gone to court over. Usually they prefer to settle out of court when they're getting sued, but when they're suing, the prosecute all the way.

Disney's lawyers do their job, and do it VERY well.
 

Worldphile

New Member
Originally posted by mktiggerman



They were stolen... there's no other way to get them off property. Being that they were stolen from private property located within a privately-run legal jurisdiction, I am not sure what it specifically is. Also, since Disney conducts its own private investigations, I believe they will get something



I don't know what the insurance is on something that they made... ex- can you insure a car that you personally manufactured. I doubt they insure the costumes.




there's always civil court..

You can insure absoutley anything. Works of art are insured all the time. So, if Disney wanted to, they could insure the costumes against theft.

Disney can investigate all they want, but law enforcement and prosecution will be handled by the local authorities. Not Disney. Disney will have to turn over all the evidence they find to law enforcement if they want to pursue these guys crimnally. So the Orange County state's attorneys office will decide whether to prosecute or not. Not Disney.

All crimes have a statute of limitations. The more minor the crime, the shorter the statute of limitations. Some crimes, like murder, have an infinite statute of limitations. You can be prosecuted for murder until you die. Other crimes, like misdemeanor theft will have a short SOL like 5 years. So, authorities only have 5 years to find and prosecute the offenders.

I'm not sure what civil remedies Disney may have in Florida, which is why I mentioned the royalties angle.
 

mkt

When a paradise is lost go straight to Disney™
Premium Member
this isn't petty theft though... this is grand theft. Each of those costumes is worth over $5000 each... the statute of limitations for this would be considerable
 

mkt

When a paradise is lost go straight to Disney™
Premium Member
Originally posted by Worldphile
I'm not sure what civil remedies Disney may have in Florida, which is why I mentioned the royalties angle.

what royalties? These aren't licensed products that are being sold... these are stolen, Disney manufactured, Disney owned, costume items, which are NEVER sold to the general public. I think royalties would be the last worry
 

Worldphile

New Member
Originally posted by mktiggerman
this isn't petty theft though... this is grand theft. Each of those costumes is worth over $5000 each... the statute of limitations for this would be considerable

I doubt it would be more than 10 years even for felony theft. In Illinois only Class X felonies like rape, murder, home invasion, etc have infinite statute of limitations. Most of the others are less than 10 years.

So, IF these are in fact stolen, it would have to be fairly recently to be prosecuted successfully.
 

Worldphile

New Member
Originally posted by mktiggerman


what royalties? These aren't licensed products that are being sold... these are stolen, Disney manufactured, Disney owned, costume items, which are NEVER sold to the general public. I think royalties would be the last worry

Royalties would be one way to get at these guys since the chances of getting at them criminally are nil.

And. You can go after people that use yor logos, copyrights, etc. for royalties even if they didn't license them. I know for a fact that in addition to suing for infringement, the University of Notre Dame does this all the time. They get their cut from whatever revenue the guy using their logos generated.
 

mkt

When a paradise is lost go straight to Disney™
Premium Member
Originally posted by Worldphile
So, IF these are in fact stolen, it would have to be fairly recently to be prosecuted successfully.

how else would they be out on Ebay then? These aren't items which are sold to the public. The only 3 companies on earth who can get their hands on these are (obviously) Disney, (just as obvious) Oriental Land Co, and (not so obvious) Feld Entertainment (for Disney on Ice).

And judging that the tag on at least 1 of the costume pieces clearly says 'Magic Kingdom', these were at one time in WDW. Plus, the date of Manufacture is 1982, not the date of theft. These could have just as easily been stolen from a storage warehouse a month ago.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom