We have done both spirit of Aloha & the Hoop Dee Doo Review, both cat-2 cause of DDP, both seating was great. The SoA we sat back on a plat form area and it actually was good becasue it started to reain during the show and the folks in front were getting misted from the rain. Also with this location I do not really think there is a bad seat in the house.
The Hoop Dee Doo Review, our seats were upstairs facing stage we were in the right side, overlooking the stage. The CM interact with everyone, so if you are dead set on have floor seatign this is the only place then you would have to pay the extra for the Cat. 1
remember this is Disney and they are aware that everyone wants the best seat in the house so they try to make them all the best seats.