Last time I went back in July we asked the manager about the crab and he said that the crab legs are a permanent addition to the menu. They were delicious with the drawn butter!!!
We went to Cape May for the first time last year and it jumped right to the top of our favorite resturant list. They had a great selection, they kept everything stocked so you never had to wait around for more crab legs. The drinks were really good too. We went pretty late at night, i think a little after 8, so it wasn't too busy or loud. The ONLY bad thing about it is getting there/going back to your hotel after.
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.