A tip...you are going to get a lot of people saying this one or that one are their faves. And the suggestions that are these people's faves are probably GREAT choices, but if it's in the budget, go for the resort that suits you best - with or without holiday decor. I still have regrets over our 2010 trip and choosing for the holiday decorations over the resort itself (not that it was a bad resort...just not me). Like @sxeensweet noted- you can still visit all of the resorts and check out the holiday decorations.
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.