I completely agree. There are very few reservations that you can't get a few months in advance and there are plenty you can get the day before if you're not overly picky about times and locations. The same is true with Fastpass plus. There's this myth that pervades the fan community that you need to book dining at 180 and Fastpasses at 60 or you're totally screwed. That's just not the case.
Absolutely true, but we don't know what reservations they wanted. It is also true that there are many restaurants where it is absolutely necessary to make your reservations 180 days out. I don't think its being picky as much as one might have a favorite or a "must do". But I agree there is always a table available somewhere. Same with fp's.