But you’re buying it for 2025. It’s not as if you’re paying for December without any benefits. So why not buy it ahead of time?
There are too many unknowns. Here are a few:
MS told me that the MMB member needs to buy a 5 day ticket for himself/herself to buy for others. This could be a complication for people that have APs already. This answer was just one that has gone around MS because it's not clear in the terms and conditions and FAQs.
There's no clarity about the OTU point system whether needing to buy 12 points to get 12 points (all or nothing). Then, working with idea that it's not all or nothing, does bonus only apply to first purchase or every purchase up until 12 Imagine buying 2 points and getting 2 bonus points, and then later buying 5 would you get 5 bonus points. MS can't answer this.
The character meet language I brought up earlier is real (no resort reservation needed for lounge access, but yes a reservation is needed to meet characters). It doesn't effect me because I'm only there on a regular resort reservation but it's going to bother people (mostly locals) who are turned away from character meet without a reservation.
DL ticket benefit is apparently unclear what ticket dates are peak and not peak? I'm not invested in this so going off what others have said.
It's unclear what tickets would a wholly unused ticket be eligible to upgrade to (someone on Disboards mentioned this).
We've learned that benefits do apply to others on the contract, that MMB applies to only one DVC member. This complicates things like priority lounge access if I am is the MMB member but I'm back at the room sick. We would both be on the reservation but they wouldn't let her use benefits.
Unless either believing you're buying OTU points or you'll be at WDW when the program starts there's reason to purchase now when others will be the guinea pigs. Even though I still plan to buy, maybe more comes out that dissuades me (lounge thing annoys me, and one way around is to have a family tier).