I just looked at the website, I don't see those places advertise themselves as quick service walk-in restaurants with first come first served seating.
Yet that's what Disney does on its website and guide maps, even if it's a flat out lie, as you could get there at rope drop and still not get a seat, due to it being Fastpass only.
Some people here really seem to be misunderstanding my point - I never said Be Our Guest was a failure, but that the concept of a daytime regular quick service, and a night time table service, has been a failure, as the only way they've kept it going has been to close the quick service walk-up and wait-your-turn aspect, and turn it into a reservation only restaurant instead.
My point was anyone trying to do the same thing at DAK as Be Our Guest tried when it first opened should look at the things that went wrong, and what went right, and learn from it. Make it reservation only from the start, *then* open up to casual guests if capacity allows, but don't go the route of pretending you can walk-up when you can't.