The 2-disc POTC was the cheapest movie ever sold down here staight from release. I haven't bought it yet, cause I don't buy "new" movies anymore, because lots of the "old" movies I want have been discontinued, so I'm working my way down based on release date. And besides, couple of months later, you can get good discounts if you don't rush for a movie on release... Anyways, I obviously wanna get it, and I'd definately favor the 3-disc set. However, if the extras are redundant... It'd be nice if it had more stuff on the attraction FOR the DVD player, instead of only DVD-ROM features like the one we have now.