It's funny that I've seen cost difference mentioned several times. We rented DVC points for our upcoming trip in October. 5 nights in an OKW studio is only about $100 more (total) than 5 nights at POP. POFQ runs about $80-100 more/night than POP. To me that's a no brainer.
We've stayed at both. 2 or 3 times at POFQ and about 5 times at OKW. We're big Key West geeks (the real one , you know, down in the Keys) and I find the architecture and landscaping quite reminiscent of the real one. Not nearly enough bars and live music though. Our accommodations were...
I would echo JIMINYCR's opinion. We were there last November and had the very same dishes. The food and service were both quite good. After dinner we spent a couple of hours in the lounge with Yehaa Bob Jackson. Great show.
Here's a few we like:
Any of the three at AKL.
Trattorio for Breakfast
Olivia's
Turf Club (although they kinda p*ssed me off by removing the filet from the menu)
Geyser Point for lunch
Polite Pig
Raglan Road
Anytime Mrs. P and I stayed at Pop we requested an upper floor facing the lake. Sometimes we got it, sometimes not. As other posters stated though, it's all about the neighbors...