• The new WDWMAGIC iOS app is here!
    Stay up to date with the latest Disney news, photos, and discussions right from your iPhone. The app is free to download and gives you quick access to news articles, forums, photo galleries, park hours, weather and Lightning Lane pricing. Learn More
  • Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
    Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.

MK Villains Land Announced for Walt Disney World's Magic Kingdom

Incomudro

Well-Known Member
I don't think anyone is naive enough to think Disney wants to go *dark*, but I do think they can gear some rides toward teenagers and not children. It's okay for the premier ride of Villains Land to be intense. It doesn't have to be Velocicoaster, but it can be a thrill that doesn't chase a seven year old's affection. They have an entire park to do that in. IMO, it should be on the level of Fantasmic in 'scaryness'. Little kids get scared and cry at Fantasmic all the time because their imaginations run wild (ironic), but that doesn't mean it's necessarily scary to the average person.
Plus, this is a new land.
It would be ok for its vibe to be darker
 
Your attempt to rebut my argument demonstrates why you started with an ad hominem attack. You make the assumption that no thrill coasters means no tension, a completely unfounded leap in logic - a thrill coasters doesn’t induce tension. Tension will come from the design and aesthetic of the land and the show elements on the rides. Your suggestion that it’s ok because the ride will be tucked away in the corner of the park is silly, as though an attractions distance from the park hub lessens the need for it to be intelligently designed in a way that aligns with the philosophy of the park. You also suggest the land should appeal to adults because children are inherently terrified of and deterred by the very appearance of Captain Hook or Gaston, a very silly position that the current state of the parks, with villains present in many areas, belies. In fact, that’s an argument in favor of a family-oriented park being careful about how it presents any spooky elements to avoid alienating children, not that an area should be built only to appeal to adults like you!
The issue with this is assuming that people only want the land to appeal to adults or children. People are saying it should appeal to older children. It can appeal to children without being "New Fantasyland 2: Electric Boogalo - Now Featuring Black and Purple Paint!". It should be aiming for something a little different than the youngest crowd, but when you hear that it is going to have the same tone as the villains show in Hollywood Studios, I think that is a very valid concern considering how corny that ended up seeming. They're going from featuring the more serious villains in the Disney catalog (Maleficent, Evil Queen, Jafar, Scar) to the ones that are goofy (Yzma, Captain Hook, Hades). The other issue is by doing this, the younger ones STILL may be too scared to enter the land. It's trying to capture too broad of a tent and that may prevent it from being what it could be.
 

mickEblu

Well-Known Member
Another thing to consider there is so much more you can do with a Maleficent boat ride. An immersive coaster is much harder to pull off. Something like the Yzma / pull the lever is kind of shallow enough to where expectations are likely to be met/ surpassed. Also considering MK has the worst POTC in the world a state of the art boat ride sounds like a nice idea for the park. There are a lot of half glass full ways you can look at this pivot.
 

Casper Gutman

Well-Known Member
I think people may need to rewatch some Disney films. Hook, Gaston, Cruella, Facilier, Yzma, Ursula, Hades, Queen of Hearts - they aren’t “dark and twisted,” they’re flamboyant and excessive. They get the big showtunes and the funny lines. A few, like Ursula or Gaston, get darker in the last ten minutes, but that’s not the element of the character people like or remember. Posters here and elsewhere want a tone that doesn’t match the IP and would mangle the things that make the characters work.
 

MrPromey

Well-Known Member
Add in a couple fantasyland style dark rides featuring a different villain in each… and I’d feel set.

Boat ride makes sense for Hades over Maleficent, but they can make it work.

I need the coaster to be substantial, even if family friendly. It needs to be Big Thunder or Space Mountain length. If you’re gonna build us that moment from that film, do it right. It’s gonna be mostly appealing to Millennials …

Honestly, if they're not willing to go all-in with a teen+ concept, I'd rather have a handful of moderately priced flat dark rides basically built in a classic Fantasyland manner with modern effects that cover a combined range of characters than a big budget boat ride, coaster, and yet another spinner.

It would increase capacity/variety and would probably age better in a multi-generational nostalgia sense. That way, we could have a SWSA or MTWR style attraction in there amongst all the rest and everyone would be happy... except Disney of course since they won't get a new ILL to up-charge for out of it.
 

Bleed0range

Well-Known Member
I think people may need to rewatch some Disney films. Hook, Gaston, Cruella, Facilier, Yzma, Ursula, Hades, Queen of Hearts - they aren’t “dark and twisted,” they’re flamboyant and excessive. They get the big showtunes and the funny lines. A few, like Ursula or Gaston, get darker in the last ten minutes, but that’s not the element of the character people like or remember. Posters here and elsewhere want a tone that doesn’t match the IP and would mangle the things that make the characters work.

I never actually thought the land was going to be “scary,” from the get go. I just thought it would look that way in a fun way. And those characters would simply inhabit it.

What is the visual for “villains” then, if not maleficents castle? That seems the obvious choice so then what is the architecture going to be?

I would still argue that the fun of it is the place looks spooky but the villains are silly (as always)… and perhaps they’re inviting you into their safe haven to see it’s not so bad being bad.
 

Mike S

Well-Known Member
I think people may need to rewatch some Disney films. Hook, Gaston, Cruella, Facilier, Yzma, Ursula, Hades, Queen of Hearts - they aren’t “dark and twisted,” they’re flamboyant and excessive. They get the big showtunes and the funny lines. A few, like Ursula or Gaston, get darker in the last ten minutes, but that’s not the element of the character people like or remember. Posters here and elsewhere want a tone that doesn’t match the IP and would mangle the things that make the characters work.
This is actually kind of what I’m thinking with the coaster idea I posted right above you though I didn’t specify it. That ride would be a bit more light hearted and show some funny interactions between the “lesser” villains.

The Shanghai boat ride that would include Maleficent, Hades, Jafar and other more powerful threats would be less lighthearted but nothing terrifying. Just more of these guys meaning a bit more business.
 

Bleed0range

Well-Known Member
This is actually kind of what I’m thinking with the coaster idea I posted right above you though I didn’t specify it. That ride would be a bit more light hearted and show some funny interactions between the “lesser” villains.

The Shanghai boat ride that would include Maleficent, Hades, Jafar and other more powerful threats would be less lighthearted but nothing terrifying. Just more of these guys meaning a bit more business.

All the rides should feature multiple villains. It shouldn’t be an Emperors New Groove coaster, it should be a coaster in this land they live in and Kronk pulls the wrong lever to start the coaster. But the coaster and boat ride both pass other scenes of villains just doing their thing.
 

SirLink

Well-Known Member
I think people may need to rewatch some Disney films. Hook, Gaston, Cruella, Facilier, Yzma, Ursula, Hades, Queen of Hearts - they aren’t “dark and twisted,” they’re flamboyant and excessive. They get the big showtunes and the funny lines. A few, like Ursula or Gaston, get darker in the last ten minutes, but that’s not the element of the character people like or remember. Posters here and elsewhere want a tone that doesn’t match the IP and would mangle the things that make the characters work.
That is why the Horned King should of been the main inspiration
 

Jedi14

Well-Known Member
I kinda hope the dark ride does end up having a a lot of villains. I’m not sure how interesting a whole ride with just Maleficent and her henchmen would be even if you have her turn into a dragon at the end.
I’m hoping it’s something like The Queen and some of the other villains need us to retrieve something from Maleficent. So it is Maleficent focused, but the other villains have a role.
 

Mike S

Well-Known Member
All the rides should feature multiple villains. It shouldn’t be an Emperors New Groove coaster, it should be a coaster in this land they live in and Kronk pulls the wrong lever to start the coaster. But the coaster and boat ride both pass other scenes of villains just doing their thing.
Yes that’s what I’ve said lol
 

Casper Gutman

Well-Known Member
I never actually thought the land was going to be “scary,” from the get go. I just thought it would look that way in a fun way. And those characters would simply inhabit it.

What is the visual for “villains” then, if not maleficents castle? That seems the obvious choice so then what is the architecture going to be?

I would still argue that the fun of it is the place looks spooky but the villains are silly (as always)… and perhaps they’re inviting you into their safe haven to see it’s not so bad being bad.
You highlight a key point here - people’s conception of this area seem to be that it will be “Maleficentland,” with most of the aesthetic taken from that one character. That’s not unreasonable, because that’s largely what the art we’ve seen has shown. It just isn’t very interesting and shortchanges the more entertaining villains.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom