Looks like The Zoo is officially lights out ONLY for the remainder of the season, which to me is a massive downgrade. It's devaluing one of the two new houses of the event in favor of a gimmick.
I wish I could tell you my impression of The Zoo; alas, I only got to go through once during my previous visit and tonight it was lights out even from second one of the Boofet early entry. So ultimately I can't really judge it one way or another, and that frustrates me.
I'm sure some people are pumped for this move, and I completely understand it logistically. But it really represents to me a failure on both a park level and a guest experience level.
It's a failure on a park level because for whatever reason they did not foresee that the lights off version would be dramatically more popular, something that presumably any child or teenager could have told them had they been asked. The only other lights off maze I'm aware of with SF (and I'm sure there were several) was Trick or Treat, which was already an established maze that was past its prime when it pivoted to the gimmick. Doing this during the first year a maze opens is just asking for trouble IMO. Reportedly there were evenings when the wait for the maze was an hour at 1 or 2 AM, which shocks me a lot less than it apparently did the Knott's team.
It's a failure on the guest experience level because this is a prime example of giving people what they think they want, but at the end of the day everyone ends up with a worse experience. It's a pitch that writes itself: Go through a maze with the lights off?!?!? COOL! Except:
1.) Now the line moves much slower because there are only so many flashlights, and guests will move slower through the maze because they have to work harder to see where they're going.
2.) The performers now have to deal with flashlights in their eyes all night, which will happen even if the guests aren't intentionally trying to shine their light in the wrong places.
3.) You can't as easily appreciate the design and detail that went into the maze because it's wasted on you in the dark. Even if you do catch something, you can't appreciate it in as much detail or for as long as you could have if the maze was lit appropriately.
When one of the two new mazes underwhelms and the other one is The Zoo, it doesn't really reflect all that well on Scary Farm.