Which film is worse?

[DisneyJunkie]

This question is between two particular superhero films, "Superman IV: The Quest for Peace" and "Batman & Robin". Both of these are bad almost beyond comprehension. But which would you say is worse than the other?

Examples of what makes each one so bad:

Superman IV: In the very beginning, Superman has to help some Russian cosmonauts in space. One of them is outside in full astronaut suit and gear to protect him from space. In the very end of the film, Nuclear Man has snatched up a woman from the city and has flown her into space where she has absolutely NO protection AND IS ABLE TO BREATHE just floating in the airless, freezing, vacuum of space.

Batman & Robin: Every single ice-related joke by Mr. Freeze. The stupid smile on Bruce Wayne's face as he mentions how Alfred is dying. The ridiculous Bat-credit card....and the list goes on.

 

[acishere]

Batman & Robin is a much better comedy than a lot of actual comedies.

 

[DisneyGuyNYC]

At least I sort of enjoy watching B&R. It's a bunch of nonsense and garbage but it's bizarre brightly colored garbage with super attractive people and hilariously bad ideas going on.

SIV was just trash.

 

[captainkidd]

Superman IV only because I had come to expect so much more of a Superman film, even after III. I had no expectations from B&R. The biggest problem I found with Supes IV is how could the special effects be so much worse than the original 9 years earlier?

 

[StarWarsGirl]

Can't vote, neither seen either of them. But now I definitely won't be watching either of them. Thanks for that.

 

[bsiev1977]

I look at Batman and Robin like an episode of the old TV show, which I love. So, I can enjoy it in that regard.

Superman IV is an especially smelly lump of crap, that would stand out in a room full of smelly lumps of crap. Nothing positive can be said about it.

 

[Bob Saget]

The ridiculous Bat-credit card....and the list goes on.