• The new WDWMAGIC iOS app is here!
    Stay up to date with the latest Disney news, photos, and discussions right from your iPhone. The app is free to download and gives you quick access to news articles, forums, photo galleries, park hours, weather and Lightning Lane pricing. Learn More
  • Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
    Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.

WDW Ride Safety

Did Knee

Active Member
Original Poster
In light of the recent events at Six Flags Texas and Cedar Point, I thought it might be a good time to discuss ride safety at WDW. I recently found a website that lists injury statistics by park and ride. http://www.amusementsafety.org/park_safety13.asp I found it interesting and informative, but would like the input of our forum community regarding WDW parks and rides on this list and any injuries they may have witnessed or heard about. This website seems to show that WDW is statistically MUCH safer then the rest of the industry, but I thought this topic was important and worth discussing in detail.
 

tinkerblonde11

Well-Known Member
I noticed the high amount on Dinosaur, but I cannot say I'm surprised with the jerking motions. My family has never had discomfort from the ride but I can understand if someone has had back or neck problems before that it can definitely cause a stir.
 

Wall-e

Well-Known Member
I think there's two factors involved in roller coaster safety that come to mind here regarding this accident and those are ride attendant training and attentiveness and how a rider fits in the ride.
From disneys perspective their safety record is a product of their hiring principles. Surrounding yourself with good people is never a bad investment.
As far as in ride safety that's a touchy subject. Based on what I read on cnn.com the victim may have been on had an issue with not fitting properly in the seat. I had a similar experience on BTM when I rode as a 8yo with my Grandmom. I was and am very skinny and she was not so much so the lap bar did not come all the way down on me and I moved all over the car.
Now I think also that disney's record has a lot to do with not having so many extreme coasters that you find at the likes of six flags also.
 

bsiev1977

Well-Known Member
Looking at the Disney stats on that site, something stands out.
The death at Six Flags is looking like one of a few things happened:
-rider did not follow all safety instructions
-ride attendant failed to make sure the victim was properly secured in her seat
-mechanical failure of the ride itself

The Disney injuries listed on the site all seem to be things that happen because of the nature of the rides. Like all the back and neck injuries from rides like Dinosaur, RNRC, Star Tours, etc.
 

Did Knee

Active Member
Original Poster
I noticed the high amount on Dinosaur, but I cannot say I'm surprised with the jerking motions. My family has never had discomfort from the ride but I can understand if someone has had back or neck problems before that it can definitely cause a stir.


Indiana Jones at Disneyland has the same issues, so I have to agree, this is related to the erratic motion of this ride system.
 

Did Knee

Active Member
Original Poster
My biggest surprise on this list is no injuries listed for Test Track or Tower of Terror. Test Track I can kind of understand, no real sudden motion despite the speed run, but I know several people who dodge TOT like the plague as they feel the ride makes them ill.
 

bsiev1977

Well-Known Member
My biggest surprise on this list is no injuries listed for Test Track or Tower of Terror. Test Track I can kind of understand, no real sudden motion despite the speed run, but I know several people who dodge TOT like the plague as they feel the ride makes them ill.

Remember, the stats listed on the site you originally linked to are "reported".
People most likely won't report feeling nauseous after a ride.
Plus, ToT's extreme motion is straight up and down. To me, this makes it far less likely to cause back and neck pain, the way a ride that quickly moves side to side might.
 

fillerup

Well-Known Member
By coincidence, 2nd Q injuries were reported in today's O'Sentinel by Jason Garcia. Pretty tame stuff really.

"Walt Disney World reported three guest injuries during the second quarter of this year, according to updated figures.

It's the fewest number of quarterly injuries reported by Orlando's largest theme-park resort since the final three months of 2010, state records show.

The injuries include a 36-year-old woman with a pre-existing condition who suffered a seizure on Kali River Rapids in Disney's Animal Kingdom; a 56-year-old man who experienced dizziness, chest pain and lower abdominal pain aboard Space Mountain in the Magic Kingdom; and a 62-year-old man with a pre-existing condition who suffered chest pain on the Haunted Mansion in the Magic Kingdom."

Full Article
 

SkipperButler

Active Member
Plus, ToT's extreme motion is straight up and down. To me, this makes it far less likely to cause back and neck pain, the way a ride that quickly moves side to side might.

I remember there was a frequent Guest Assistance Pass user who was told she was using it too often at Tower of Terror. Her argument was that she had back problems and the ride actually helped relieve the pain.
 

reptar77

Well-Known Member
I had a similar experience on BTM when I rode as a 8yo with my Grandmom. I was and am very skinny and she was not so much so the lap bar did not come all the way down on me and I moved all over the car.


This happens to me all the time when I ride with my husband. I slip and slide all around and then get crushed up against the side by him. I usually end up the bruises on my legs. I'm thinking of riding solo.
 

ajrwdwgirl

Premium Member
I too slide around all the time when I ride BTM with my husband, although it is kind of fun I never worried about sliding out before. I wonder if they will ever add individual seatbelts or lap bars to this ride?
 

Soarin2u

Well-Known Member
Honestly, I feel that Disney ranks top for safety. Yes, some rides with jerking motions can cause issues but people who know they have neck or back problems should really be careful with what they select to ride. Then I again I can see why I would cause someone to have issues that don't have neck or back pains,:P that's what Dinosaur does to me. Even then, I feel that Disney's constant inspections, well trained CMs, and strong engineering has paid off. It's just the matter of how stupid someone is to get themselves in danger. *Cough* bobsleds *Cough* Also considering the high amount of attendance every year, I would have expected more issues but it seems to have very few compared to how many people attend.
Just this week I visited the Mall of America. I was the only one in my family to get a band to go to the Nickelodeon Universe. I was not impressed with the employees there and how they seemed to lack to care. The Orange Sreak workers were extremely hateful and didn't even bother to check if our bar was secure. I rode it twice at separate times of day, with different employees, and it didn't happen either time. The bars also lacked the sense of security I have at Disney where it neatly pushes into my lap. These ones had a good 10 inches from my lap, enough for me to fear of letting go to raise my hands. It just seemed like I was unable to pull it down to fit and no worker came to help me. Another one was the Log Chute ride there. I rode alone so there was no one to stop me in this situation. Rather than being seated, you sat on a bench with your legs on either side. So what happened when that log went downhill with no one to cushion you? Slip! You slip on the wet seat and ram into the the single back rest that broke up either bench! Ow! That surely knocked the wind out of me! Luckily I didn't get wet. Yet I found myself getting on the ride again just because I found so much amusement in myself singing the song for Splash Mountian and /or IASW. These are issues that I have would have NEVER run into before at Disney!
 

Sassagoula-Rvr

Well-Known Member
You know what, one time right before the park closed...I wasn't 100% my Space Mountain restraint was working properly...I said what the heck and just held on for dear life...but now thinking about recent events...pretty scary! Although, it was probably just my paranoia :cautious:
 

tare

Well-Known Member
I feel pretty safe with the rides at wdw and dl. But they don't always have the brightest most realizable workers chking out all the safety chks. But I feel it is like that in most amusement parks. Just have to think positive.
 

rct247

Well-Known Member
There are quite a few factors that go with this. For one, Disney isn't known for thrill rides and roller coasters. Those attractions tend to bring on more injuries and illnesses. Disney attractions tend to be more tame. Another factor is the ride systems have many safety features whether there are sensors, cameras, indicators, checkpoints, etc that detect problems and in some cases automatically stop themselves. A good number of attractions at Disney have "intrusion systems" which detect if a guest or cast member are where they are not supposed to be either exploring the attraction or jumping out. Other systems space vehicles out automatically or stop motion if a restraint sensor or abnormality is found. One of the last major factors is training. Cast members are nearly drilled to death over safety procedures. Cast are trained extensively at attractions to know how they operate and how to respond to specific situations. Each attraction has a very detailed checklist that is used when opening in the morning. Everything is checked from restraints to emergency stops to making sure signage is in place, supplies are ready, and facilities are in good condition. Cast members are audited every year on how they would respond to general situations at their locations from what to do if they experience something out of the ordinary to locating the nearest automatic external defibrillator if needed. Speaking of AED machines, Disney is the best place to have a heart attack in the world due to the number of quickly accessible AED machines that could save a life during and after a heart attack. Other parks do have aspects of these but not to the extent that Disney does.

You basic attraction cast member should know how to operate the attraction, how to stop the attraction under certain conditions, how to handle an emergency, how to respond if a guest jumps out of their vehicle, if their is a fire, if there is a technical difficulty, if the park was being evacuated, if there was severe weather, if there was a medical emergency, if there is a loss of power, or if there was a security threat or issue. To what level do you think the average ride operator at a competitor or local park has this level of training, how in depth was it discussed, and would they succeed in following procedure if thrown into this situation.

First hand, I have experienced being at a Six Flags park during a tornado warning requiring us to seek shelter. The employee didn't know where to go, communication was inconsistant throughout the park through all lines of business, and guests were very confused. Luckily I video taped it and sent it to Six Flags in hopes that it was a fluke or an eye opener. Sure there were emergency procedures in place, but did their employees know those procedures.

Looking back at situations at Disney, someone around always knew what to do to a good extent even if they were not entirely sure, were uncomfortable, or somewhat nervous about what was happening.

Of course all this said, accidents do happen everywhere and sometimes they are truly accidents. Companies and manufacturers learn from mistakes and accidents though whether it is through signage, training, procedures, or physical changes. No park, even Disney, are immune to them. The accidents at Six Flags over Texas and Cedar Point probably could have happened anywhere.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom