I stayed at Parade Pier because of the event rate I got for Gay Days weekend, which was between 25-30% off the rack rate. I thought it would be convenient to stay within walking distance of the parks and at a nice "Disney" hotel like I did in Florida.
You can tell it's a remodeled 80s hotel, but the rooms themselves were quite nice. Pixar balls instead of beach ball pillows, but still "paradise pier" themed for the most part. The lobby and some other areas were decorated as "Pirates Pier" for Halloween which I liked because they don't put up Halloween decorations in the WDW hotels.
Elevators are weird. There's almost no buttons inside so to pick a floor you touch the number on an ipad and it tells you which one to board (A, B, C, or D). Some times there was a long wait for one to show up.
Gym is OK, but limited to free weights, some cardio equipment and one cable machine. Naturally it wasn't busy in the morning when people were going to the parks.
Did not get a chance to go to the pool or water slide, but they looked nice.
On-site dining is limited to PCH Grill ($$$), room service or the lounges in the lobby or pool deck. Lobby lounge tries to be bar, grab-and-go and sit down eatery for breakfast and I think they would be better to build another place to eat here.
I think it was faster to take a bus from Pop Century to Magic Kingdom than take the official guest path to the parks (first north to the far west side of DTD then a hike to the main gates). Monorail was the better option IMO because they scan your ticket there and you bypass the main gate. Plus it's more fun. I tried going through Grand Californian instead but there's a gate that you need a room key to walk through. Other Disney hotels won't work, and if you had a VIP Pass for gay days (the welcome centre was near the lobby) or dining reservations you still had to walk the long way around. Bag check was also slow and the line for guests with no bags wasn't always open.
Would I stay here again? Only if I got a substantial discount like this time. Both DLH and GCH looked nicer for the kind of money this place costs and the Harbor Blvd hotels are closer to the main gates.