My American kids would eat almost everything on that menu. Except tofu, but not because it is "out there', it is just gross. The menu has steak, chicken, pork, fish, seafood, and a vegetarian dish, none of which is strange or different. All of these things can be found anywhere USA. With the exception of some tiny town. Our family has had all of the stuff that is listed on that menu at one time or another. Being raised by European parents, I was exposed to different foods and I wanted to give my kids that same experience. My fully American husband, who was raised on tater tot casserole, was not exposed to different foods. I did not want that for my kids so I took my kids to the store and involved them in the meals. We made it fun to try new things and they got very excited going to places like WDW to be able to try different foods. The only reason the 'Mericans think that any of these foods are "out there" is because they choose not to even try anything different. Which is really sad because there is so much good food out there. And America is made up of many different cultures, I don't think you can really say what the "average American" typically eats. All of these ingredients are at local markets, even in the mid west, where I live. So people obviously do eat these things. FYI, my kids LOVE lamb.