• The new WDWMAGIC iOS app is here!
    Stay up to date with the latest Disney news, photos, and discussions right from your iPhone. The app is free to download and gives you quick access to news articles, forums, photo galleries, park hours, weather and Lightning Lane pricing. Learn More
  • Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
    Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.

Fake Disney Merchandise in China

hcswingfield

Active Member
Original Poster
Associated Press article from today's online Miami Herald (9.16.05). Some interesting stuff!

SHENZHEN, China - Fancy a Mickey Mouse stuffed toy in vampire outfit with fangs? How about a matching set of black-and-white Mickey Mouse bra and underpants?
They're among the more glaring knockoffs of Disney products on sale in the myriad small shops in the southern China boomtown of Shenzhen, just an hour away from Hong Kong -- home to the newest Disneyland.

With the opening of the theme park Sept. 12, counterfeit Disney products manufactured in mainland China have flooded the markets in Hong Kong as licensed retailers struggle to keep up with demand.

The sheer variety of fake Disney products on display in Shenzhen's bustling Dongmen (East Gate) market is astounding: Mickey Mouse steel wristwatches, Winnie the Pooh clocks, Mickey and Minnie stuffed toys, T-shirts, silver and orange-colored Mickey handbags, wallets and bed sheets.

Despite the products' inferior quality, customers say they are drawn by the bargain prices.

''My children love Disney cartoon characters. The genuine clothes are too expensive. I don't mind if they are fake as long as they are wearable,'' said housewife Xiong Feng, whose 4-year-old daughter and 3-year-old son were donning pirated Mickey Mouse outfits.

For 75 Chinese yuan (U.S. $9), shoppers can get a fake Disney wristwatch -- about one-third the price of a genuine one. The cape-clad Mickey vampire toy is on sale for 30 yuan ($3.70), while a set of Mickey underwear costs just 20 yuan (U.S. $2.50).

A SERIOUS CONCERN

Disney executives acknowledge that piracy is a serious concern for them.

''It's broad. It's everywhere, from our DVD business to our packaged goods, our consumer products, and everything in between,'' said Douglas Miller, executive vice president and managing director of The Walt Disney Co. (Asia Pacific).

''It's a multiple hundreds-of-billions-of-dollars-notjust-Disney issue. It's very significant in all areas,'' he said.

To combat counterfeiting, Miller said Disney works with Hong Kong Customs and mainland Chinese authorities for market sweeps and keeps close contact with retailers. He declined to give details.

In August, the company introduced a new security tag -- a three-dimensional holographic label -- to identify genuine Hong Kong Disneyland merchandise, sold at two retail outlets at the Hong Kong airport. It is also on sale at the park.

CUSTOM CRACKDOWNS

In recent weeks, Hong Kong custom officials also stepped up measures to crack down on counterfeit goods featuring Disney as well as Japanese cartoon characters, including raids on several local markets. In one raid, officers seized about 37,500 pirated toys, stationery, handbags and electric appliances worth about 1.5 million Hong Kong dollars (about U.S. $193,100).

Officials said the sellers usually mixed genuine products with fake ones in order to evade customs inspection.

Both licensed mainland Chinese and Hong Kong manufacturers of Disney products complain that rampant piracy hurts their business.

Alice Cheng, marketing manager of Grand Smart International Development, a Disney licensee in Hong Kong, said her company would conduct frequent inspections of local markets and report sightings of counterfeit products to Disney.

But across the border, Disney is facing a tougher war in the clampdown on piracy as local media reported that some mainland factories authorized to produce genuine products sometimes make fake goods on the side.

''We are very angry,'' said Zhang Fan, who is in charge of the Shenzhen operations of Youngjun Leather International Co., a Disney licensee of leather products with about 500 stores on the mainland.

''The counterfeiters would copy our new designs just days after they were launched,'' Zhang said. ``They are really fast and sell the fake goods near our own stores at much cheaper prices.''

Zhang said his company has notified Disney about the fakes, but they haven't directly contacted mainland authorities because he says their contract with Disney does not authorize them to do this.

He said business is affected but declined to give an estimate.

Disney executives expect the Hong Kong theme park -- a joint venture between the company and the Hong Kong government -- to draw throngs of mainland visitors, but whether the company can successfully tackle the piracy issue remains to be seen.
 

gsimpson

Well-Known Member
I feel sorry for Disney but.....

On the other hand, Disney has moved more and more of their product manufacturing to China in recent years fully aware that China is the center of piracy of all things. Most every company in most every industry can tell you chapter and verse that when you have an agreement with a subcontractor in China to make your goods they will make some for you and lots for them. It has been going on for years but the bean counters don't care as long as they save a buck. Since they chose to put local manufacturers out of business and US citizens out of work by moving to a cheaper labor market (and dropping the quality a lot in the process) and turned over the intellectual property to China to save their buck I can only hope that they get burned but good, hopefully losing a few billion will cause them to rethink save a few million (although I doubt it). In all likelyhood you will see pirated product actually sold out of Hong Kong Disneyland, just as you see knock off Sony products sold out of sony retailers in Hong Kong.

Of course, they moved the jobs, wages, and taxes to China but will now want the US taxpayers to foot the bill to try and enforce the anti-piracy laws. Who says you can't have your cake and eat it too. It is nearly impossible to stop the piracy when it is being done by your manufacturing "partner".
 

bgraham34

Well-Known Member
I dont feel Sorry for Disney, they know how China is with the Knock offs. they should lower the prices on items and this would not happen. Some Asian countries pirated goods outsell regular goods. Its not like us in the U.S. were you would rather buy the real thing. In some respects anyways.
 

Edeyore

New Member
60 Minutes had done a story on Chinese knock-offs of all kinds of products.
Disney, I am sure, would be aware of this, and probably expected a certain
amount of it to happen. It will just be tough now to distinguish which is the
official Disney products made in China and the one ordered by Disney, made
in China.
 

joel_maxwell

Permanent Resident of EPCOT
DisneyFreak529 said:
I own a few knock off Louis Vuttion handbags so I guess I can't really coment on this topic.
:lol:
my wife did too....... until they kept falling apart (the zippers, strap) so instead of buying tons of knock offs, i told her to go buy the real thing. she calls it "her one big indulgence" in the accessory department.

fine with me...... i went and got a new table saw :D
 

Yukinon

New Member
I can't really comment either I have bought many knock-off products and probably will in the future. There is an Asian-import store in my town that sells things dirt-cheap - I found a little Hello Kitty bag for $1.50 where I had seen one in a different store very simiar for over 12 bucks - I went for the cheaper one :D
 

RoninHood

New Member
yea i just got my fake cast member badge today in chinatown from some of old guy who tried to sell me something called a mogawi,but i refused,the rules,something bout not getting it wet,who knows.
but i did pick up a smokeless ash tray for my mom.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom