Dont get hurt on a Disney Cruise

PoohsGang

New Member
After reading this, if its true Id be asking for 75 Million, not thousand.......an 8 mile journey in a raft just doesn't sound fun in the Ocean anyways.....

A widow from New York has sued Disney Cruse Line in federal court, blaming the company for her husband’s death from injuries he suffered during a Mediterranean cruise last summer.

Marilyn Piazza alleges that her husband, Santo L. Piazza, died because a poorly designed, raised threshold on a bathroom doorway caused him to trip and fall; because the ship’s medical staff initially misdiagnosed his injuries; and because efforts to evacuate him to a shore hospital for emergency medical treatment were slow, poorly planned and poorly executed. Santo Piazza died Aug. 14 at age 78.



Marilyn Piazza filed the lawsuit Thursday on behalf of her husband’s estate in U.S. District Court in Orlando. Her complaint identifies the cruise line’s corporate entity, Magical Cruise Co. Ltd., and Disney Cruise Vacations as defendants. She alleges that they were responsible for Santo Piazza’s wrongful death, and her suit seeks more than $75,000.

Her complaint states that her husband was injured while they and their daughter and her family were beginning an 11-day cruise out of Barcelona, Spain, aboard the Disney Magic.

The suit gives this account: Santo Piazza tripped over the raised threshold while stepping into his cabin’s bathroom. He fell, and his right side struck the bathtub, causing “catastrophic internal injuries.” He immediately went to the shipboard health-services department, where he was given a Tylenol. That afternoon, he returned to the health-services department after he vomited, had shortness of breath and experienced severe pain. After his second evaluation, the ship’s doctor diagnosed him with fractured ribs and a punctured lung, requiring immediate evacuation and hospitalization.



The suit alleges that the Piazzas waited five hours before the Disney Magic altered its course toward Cagliari, Sardinia, Italy. Then ship personnel put the injured man in an inflatable raft and transported him through eight miles of choppy waves to the shore, “crashing and smashing Mr. Piazza up and down constantly.”


The suit also complains that no one from Disney Cruise Line went ashore with him to assist. He was accompanied only by his son-in-law; neither of them spoke Italian, and none of the Italian medical personnel they met spoke English.



Santo Piazza died from his injuries 17 days later, according to the complaint.



Marilyn Piazza could not be reached Friday for comment. Her lawyers at the law firm of Moore & Co. in Miami declined to discuss the case.


A Disney Cruise Line spokeswoman declined to comment, citing Disney’s policy of not discussing pending litigation.
 

sknydave

Active Member
The bathrooms on every cruise ship I've been on have that elevated step. They also had a sign saying watch your step.

I believe 75k is the minimum amount needed to sue for in federal court.

I really don't get the whole idea behind suing a company for wrongful death. Ok my husband is dead.. Now I want to be rich? I don't get it.
 
Upvote 0

Pioneer Hall

Well-Known Member
The raft may have been done if there were no other options. Usually they will try and call in the Coast Guard and fly a person out...but who knows why they didn't. And, as the previous poster said...there are signs telling you to watch your step. The bathrooms on cruises are small and they have to have the elevated lip so water doesn't get everywhere. It's unfortunate that this happened, but I feel that suing isn't the way to take care of it. I am sure the medical people involved have already been taken care of.
 
Upvote 0

Champion

New Member
The raft may have been done if there were no other options. Usually they will try and call in the Coast Guard and fly a person out...but who knows why they didn't. And, as the previous poster said...there are signs telling you to watch your step. The bathrooms on cruises are small and they have to have the elevated lip so water doesn't get everywhere. It's unfortunate that this happened, but I feel that suing isn't the way to take care of it. I am sure the medical people involved have already been taken care of.

They were near Italy. The Coast Guard doesn't quite guard those coasts.
 
Upvote 0

PoohsGang

New Member
Original Poster
I have quite a threshold in my bathroom also so I don't blame that, I think the fault lies with the way the medical staff handled it, even if there was no money being sought, don't you think someone is at fault, after all he did seek medical assistance?

I just think that if I was on a cruise and my Dad got hurt I would want to make sure he is evaluated properly. Like I said earlier, if this is true, someone overlooked something. Also the raft , it must have been pretty scary, it would have to be a life threatening situation for me to get in a raft in the ocean, even if its a big one.

Someone messed up......
 
Upvote 0

WDWRLD

Active Member
Im sure it wasnt a "raft" but rather a small boat. I would also have to look again but I remember either reading or being told sometime that any expense of a medivac off a ship would be at the paitents expense. Could it have been that they origionally tried a medivac but weather was too bad and they had to resort to a boat? There is probally way more to this story than is being told. Remember this is a cruise ship and not a Hospital ship this is why they dont allow passengers who are pregnant and so many weeks along of people with certian medical conditions to board the ship. They simply arent staffed to handle all medical conditions.
 
Upvote 0

PoohsGang

New Member
Original Poster
Still seems as they couldnt even handle basic care when he first went to first aid "here have a Tylenol, go lie down and we will treat you when you get worse" Just speculation on my part, I'm sure the lawyers press release only tells his clients side of the story so we may never know what really happened, I still know even if they sent me on shore in a small boat I wouldn't want to do it, the waves on shore can be pretty tough at times.
 
Upvote 0

Phonedave

Well-Known Member
Of course it's all speculation but ....

Lip on the bathroom - thats been pretty much covered

Initial assesment - People do make mistakes, sometimes symptoms don't present, and who knows what the paitent said. If you were a medic, and somebody came in and said, "I tripped in the bathroom and hit my side, now it hurts" are you going to assume internal injuries ? I don't know if this is what happend, we have no idea of the initial circumstances.

As far as the evac. As people said, maybe they tried for a heli, maybe they tried to put into a port, who knows. Maybe the reason they waited 5 hours is because they tried other options before resorting to the "rubber raft" (I'm thinking a Zodiac) and finaly resorted to that because nothing else was evailable.

Too little information to make an evaluation.

-dave
 
Upvote 0

Eyorefan

Active Member
Still seems as they couldnt even handle basic care when he first went to first aid "here have a Tylenol, go lie down and we will treat you when you get worse" Just speculation on my part, I'm sure the lawyers press release only tells his clients side of the story so we may never know what really happened, I still know even if they sent me on shore in a small boat I wouldn't want to do it, the waves on shore can be pretty tough at times.

I'm with you on this one and posted something similar in the other thread. I don't see these people as "sue happy" or out to get rich. They only asked for $75,000 which, in the legal world isn't much. I think people have to remember that there are legitimate reasons to sue a company, and I think this is one of them. For no other reason than it will probably get Disney to re-train their staff to do better evaluations of people in the future. Which will make traveling on their ships safer for all of us.
 
Upvote 0

angelfaerie52

New Member
You have to sue for 75,001 dollars or more to sue in federal court. Also, there is a clause on any cruise ship ticket requring any litigation to come out of a specified location... your friendly law student runs away now...
 
Upvote 0

Pumbas Nakasak

Heading for the great escape.
Having lived just outside Cagliari I would be surprised if a ship the size of the Disney Magic could dock there. It normally just services ferries to the mainland and Tunisia.
Perhaps it could have used the military dock a few miles further along.

As for the no English, thats not a surprise in the South of the island, tourists tend to holiday in the north.

8 miles in a zodiac is a bit of a stretch the bay of Cagliari is quite busy as theres a major petro chemical works down the coast.
 
Upvote 0

happymom52003

Active Member
When you go on any cruise, you are taking a risk. I have nothing against cruises....I've been on many of them, and will continue to do so. But....if you get seriously injured or have any type of serious medical emergency, chances are high you will not recieve proper care. First of all, the doctors on ships are not always the greatest.....I've read horror stories about them, even on major cruise lines. They also do not have the equipment to do lifesaving prodcedures. Second of all, depending on your location you may not be able to get to a major hospital in time to save your life due to the logistics of getting evacuated. And on top of that, you have to pray really hard that the nearest port they take you to has clean, modern hospitals that know what they are doing. So I just always pray really hard when we go on a cruise that my apendix does not decide to burst, or that my heart will not decide to stop beating!
I think this is one of the reasons we have not taken our kids on a cruise yet....I am super paranoid about one of them getting sick on the ship, and not being able to get to a children's hospital. I know the chances of this happening are slim, but we've had an emergeny like this with one of our kids, and we had to go straight from our pediatricians office to the childrens hospital in our city and it was a very scary nightmare. I think because of that experience I am overly worried about not being able to get proper emergeny care for my kids if they needed it. I hope I get over that someday.
 
Upvote 0

danpam1024

Well-Known Member
When you take into account there was no Disney staff sent in the boat, that must mean the boat responded to them. I interpret that as it being a "rescue" from whatever medical provider was available. His family member went with him. Was there even room for additional "Disney staff"?

Nobody should assume that a Medivac helicopter was an option. Is there a landing pad on the cruise ship? Is it large enough? If not, you now need a helicopter with a winch, which is very rare.

Normally, you cannot definitively diagnose internal injuries without an x-ray, MRI, CT, etc. Even if the MD thought it was a possibility, I'm certain the patient (older gentleman on vacation with his family) intitially refused the hassle of being evacuated off the ship for further evaluation. I expect the conversation to include a statement such as; "If you don't want to go ashore, take this pill. If the pain gets worse, or you experience more symptoms, call us immediatelly."
 
Upvote 0

bfbulldog

Member
I can't disagree with this lawsuit more. Disney wasn't responsible for the mans fall, which is what ultimately caused his demise, there are clear markings to watch your step in those bathrooms. And let's be honest, if you're expecting to see world class healthcare facilities on a cruise ship then you're in for a big surprise. The infirmary on a cruise ship is set up to handle bumps, bruises and the occasional broken bone. They don't have all the latest diagnostic equipment, MRI's, CAT Scans or the like available to diagnose potential major traumas. I'm sure everything that was feasible to be done was done. Sometimes an accident is just that, an accident and there's no one to blame. IMO, this is one of those times.
 
Upvote 0

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom