The dig site, restaurant, animal trail, and gift shop all told a really cool story. The carnival left some to be desired but when they had lucky and the jugglers, etc. it was a fun and unique vibe.
Dinoland was very hit and miss.
A restaurant with a layered theme, part cool dinosaur stuff from a paleontologist's perspective rather than as 'scary big monsters’, as in many a theme park or movie. And part a bit too convoluted. 'Nerds shooting arrows on the roof’ wasn't needed. And later additions didn’t match the vibe, a plain table outside with alcoholic drinks just looked ridiculous.
The walk-up to the Dino ride is fabulous. Great sculptures, great architecture. Every time I get super excited to walk into a great natural history museum, a bit stuck in time, as I prefer them. I forget I'm in Disney, even get a bit dissapointed when I snap out of it and remember I'm doing a ride here, can't just stop and read the descriptions. Then get excited again because yay! a fun dino-ride waits, followed by being slightly underwhelmed. In the boneworks of Dinosaur there must lie hidden a superb ride, just within reach, but they never quite found it. Not bad though, just not bull's eye.
Then the trek. Over before you've started. But really well done. You need to stop and explore the botany. I love it when WDW takes its audience seriously. Like Maharadja Trek, you need to put in the work here to get something out of it. It's not even that deep, just understanding why there are ferns and ostriches and crocodiles in this area. The mini-trek got mistly ruined since the late 2010s by character meets and infantilisation.
The gift shop is a delight, one of WDW's finest. Somewhat convoluted again, but it works. Chester and Hester though, nah, not so much. A carnival is a carnival, even as you theme it as a cheap carnival so it doesn't look like a cheap carnival, or something.
The new area might very well be better. Or not. Indy is idealised a bit, as much as I adore the theme, character and movie I&III the ride doesn't really suck me in. Confused bumping around. Still this is one of the few new projects where I think an area could end up an improvent over what was before. At face value, that is. Because it will further dilute DAK's theming and cohesion, thus story, thus immersion. Which was one of the finest works in all of Imagineering history.