MK Roger E. Broggie's New Whistle

[disneytrain2001]

I've found a new video of Roger wearing a new whistle, which sounds very similar to Roy's:

I believe this new whistle is a transitional style Crosby Schaffer & Budenberg (S&B) 5-inch diameter 3-chime.

 

[disneytrain2001]

Oh, Roger also received another new buzzer:

 

[larryz]

Nice touch catching the exchange between the train and the steamboat!

 

[Eric Graham]

That's really neat. I used to be and avid collector of trains in my youth, but only HO trains. Couldn't really afford the Lionels. But, that's alright. I always ride the train at Disney. It is always so much fun, and oh so very relaxing. I also in the past have enjoyed the trains at Stone Mountain Park in Georgia, Six Flags Over Georgia, and Dollywood of course! So much fun! So many wonderful memories of trains!! Thank you oh so much for posting! And, please keep it up!

 

[disneytrain2001]

Nice touch catching the exchange between the train and the steamboat!

I didn't take that video! But I'm glad Walter and Roger finally got new whistles that sounds more appropriate to their size.

 

[dtng2000]

I wonder why Roger has a new buzzer already…it had the original buzzer in the first video you posted.

 

[disneytrain2001]

Next month will be Walter and Roger's centennial birthday:

 

[dtng2000]

Long overdue reply but Lilly Belle also received the new buzzer a few months before the railroad went into shuttle mode.

 

[disneytrain2001]

The new whistle sounds way too low-pitched because of how sooty and dirty it looked. I wish they could polish it up to its proper sound tone like that:

 

[dtng2000]

Does anyone know which whistle was used on the Liberty Belle riverboat? The way Roger's whistle sounds currently almost makes it sound like the riverboat.

 

[disneytrain2001]

Does anyone know which whistle was used on the Liberty Belle riverboat? The way Roger's whistle sounds currently almost makes it sound like the riverboat.

Liberty Belle's whistle is a Crosby 5-inch diameter 3-chime too, albeit it's a new style version of it without the acorn top valve:

She temporarily wore a Lunkenheimer 3-inch diameter single-chime from 2018 to 2020:

 

[dtng2000]

Liberty Belle's whistle is a Crosby 5-inch diameter 3-chime too, albeit it's a new style version of it without the acorn top valve:

She temporarily wore a Lunkenheimer 3-inch diameter single-chime from 2018 to 2020:

Why not give that whistle to Lilly Belle? Because they both have the word Belle in their name lol.

 

[disneytrain2001]

Why not give that whistle to Lilly Belle? Because they both have the word Belle in their name lol.

I don't know and NO, I don't want Lilly and Roger sound way too similar to each other, wearing the same Crosby 5-inch diameter types. I prefer Lilly wearing the high-pitched Buckeye 3-inch diameter 3-chime.

 

[dtng2000]

I don't know and NO, I don't want Lilly and Roger sound way too similar to each other, wearing the same Crosby 5-inch diameter types. I prefer Lilly wearing the high-pitched Buckeye 3-inch diameter 3-chime.

Yeah that was meant to be a joke. I’ll cry if the last Buckeye gets removed. Roger's current whistle also poses a problem because now it will sound almost like Roy when he returns.

 

[disneytrain2001]

Roger's current whistle also poses a problem because now it will sound almost like Roy when he returns.

Like I said, Roger's new Crosby whistle is out of tune, and it needs to sound like this:

 

[disneytrain2001]

I want to give a correction; according to YouTuber cple1, it turns out that the Roger E. Broggie's new whistle is a Schaeffer & Budenberg (S&B) 5 inch 3-chime.

 

[dtng2000]

I want to give a correction; according to YouTuber cple1, it turns out that the Roger E. Broggie's new whistle is a Schaeffer & Budenberg (S&B) 5 inch 3-chime.
View attachment 902946

Never heard of them before!

 

[disneytrain2001]

Never heard of them before!

It's a German manufacturer company, which expand its subsidiary in Brooklyn, NY, around 1876. They used to produce steam whistles until the 1940s.