Here's my tier ratings
S-Tier:
Harry Potter and the Battle at the Ministry
Monsters Unchained: The Frankenstein Experiment
Stardust Racers
A-Tier:
Hiccup’s Wing Gliders
The Untrainable Dragon – Surprisingly emotional show. Puppetry and effects are next level.
Mario Kart: Bowser’s Challenge – Augmented reality plus chaos. Not everyone’s cup of tea but wildly impressive.
B-Tier:
Mine-Cart Madness
Le Cirque Arcanus
Curse of the Werewolf
C-Tier:
Yoshi’s Adventure
Dragon Racer’s Rally
Fyre Drill
Constellation Carousel
D-Tier:
Astronomica (it's a splash pad)
Darkmoor Monster Makeup Experience (It's a gift shop/experience pretending to be an attraction)
Viking Training Camp (it's a playround)
F-Tier
Nothing here earns an F. Even the D-Tier stuff is well themed and can be fun.

Harry Potter and the Battle at the Ministry
Monsters Unchained: The Frankenstein Experiment
Stardust Racers

Hiccup’s Wing Gliders
The Untrainable Dragon – Surprisingly emotional show. Puppetry and effects are next level.
Mario Kart: Bowser’s Challenge – Augmented reality plus chaos. Not everyone’s cup of tea but wildly impressive.

Mine-Cart Madness
Le Cirque Arcanus
Curse of the Werewolf

Yoshi’s Adventure
Dragon Racer’s Rally
Fyre Drill
Constellation Carousel

Astronomica (it's a splash pad)
Darkmoor Monster Makeup Experience (It's a gift shop/experience pretending to be an attraction)
Viking Training Camp (it's a playround)

Nothing here earns an F. Even the D-Tier stuff is well themed and can be fun.