Dranth
Well-Known Member
True.
I don't think that show in particular has much of an attachment (the in park play, not the movie) but I imagine if it was being shut down and replaced, those that did feel that way wouldn't be thrilled by it.
-
The new WDWMAGIC iOS app is here!
Stay up to date with the latest Disney news, photos, and discussions right from your iPhone. The app is free to download and gives you quick access to news articles, forums, photo galleries, park hours, weather and Lightning Lane pricing. Learn More -
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
DHS Monster Inc Land Coming to Disney's Hollywood Studios
- Thread starter wdwmagic
- Start date
I don't think that show in particular has much of an attachment (the in park play, not the movie) but I imagine if it was being shut down and replaced, those that did feel that way wouldn't be thrilled by it.
Bocabear
Well-Known Member
I love that we still have attractions that were around when I was a kid. Nostalgia really is the Disney brand... That said, there is nothing wrong with updating and plussing some of these attractions...as long as it is done in the right way that respects the original... At this point, Carousel Of Progress should either go all the way back to the World's Fair version (since they are using the original theme song) and end with the mid century modern home of the future set as the finale....or they should restore the WDW Original Carousel of Progress song and go back to the 1975 finale script and set. Either would feel more authentic than the finale scene currently being used....Then they could use some of the old Galaxy Theater land and create a proper pre-show prologue about the context of the attraction...
Give it 10 more years and its removal will generate a thousand Change.org petitions to keep it.
ToTBellHop
Well-Known Member
Captain Barbossa
Well-Known Member
doctornick
Well-Known Member
I have a bigger concern about that with the ToL show. ITTBAB was IMHO the best 4D show that Disney has ever done and Zootopia seems particularly forced into that space and a poor subject for a successful engaging show. I would be surprised if the show is even mediocre.
While I appreciate MV3D, I actually think Monsters Inc provides a good foundation for an entertaining attraction. While I don’t think it will surpass or even match MV3D, I do expect it to be a solid addition.
ToTBellHop
Well-Known Member
Eh. Post-Covid? Just get a dog.“Disappointed” and “MILF” do not coexist in the same sentence.
Trust me
JD80
Well-Known Member
Didn't say the should be removed from the discussion. But in my opinion those two things are not enough to keep something unchanged for 30+ years.
JD80
Well-Known Member
My personal opinion of course, but Peter Pan should be updated because I think it's the most overrated attraction in the park.
CoP feels old and that would be my only hypocritical opinion that it shouldn't be touched. However, I wouldn't be upset if it were moved to EPCOT or something like that (assuming that's even possible).
Small World? Should be gutted based on what you get for such a large show building. Move it to EPCOT too. I would probably be upset if they touched the one in DisneyLand.
Agent H
Well-Known Member
Thank you. I’ve been dealing with this kind of behavior from people in the parks for half the time I’ve been going and it keeps getting worse over time.
Bocabear
Well-Known Member
Imagination could become an Imagineering Pavilion....with a focus on Walt Disney's work for the World's Fair and how that changed the amusement entertainment business... Move both Small World and COP there....restored back to their World's fair era look.... and a fantastic new interactive Walt Disney museum (moving over everything from One Man's Dream.... Restore Imagination attraction back to it's original...add a few very imaginative flat rides featuring Figment outdoors in an area featuring the entrance and full outdoor facade of Small World and Carousel of Progress....It could be it's own Miniland "World Imagination"....then move the Walt statue over there admiring things he actually did create....
Dranth
Well-Known Member
Just curious, what is enough in your mind because to me, it seems like most of WDW is based on nostalgia.
Casper Gutman
Well-Known Member
The posters perpetually boosting Disney for adding “something new” would be on much stronger footing if WDW had demonstrated competence in creating new attractions. The track record is just abysmal. Rat is cute, Resistance is very good when it should have been great, and MMRR is genuinely great. Other than that, it’s a litany of lackluster misses. Disney hasn’t demonstrated that they can build an attraction as complete and clever as muppets since… Tower of Terror?
Casper Gutman
Well-Known Member
The Muppets were supposed to feel old when they were new. They’re a vaudeville troupe! That’s the charm.
The attraction itself, with its mix of AAs, projections, and effects, feels “newer” then Philharmagic or any of the other shows built since.
Casper Gutman
Well-Known Member
By the way, I assume we have all sorts of info about the big Muppets replacement. I mean, since that’ll be opening as soon as possible, it should be a year or less away, right?
BrianLo
Well-Known Member
I would slightly counter that WDW is a bit of a misrepresentation of Imagineering's capabilities. Though that output gap improved later last decade.
We're arguing in the realms of sheer subjectivity. However, there are like 30 things built since Muppets or Tower or Terror that are currently higher rated subjectively by guests. Which don't mistake me - MV3D is still quite well rated and still holds up. I still would have rather a Muppets Great Movie dark ride annex, if it were up to me.
We'll get some good idea shortly if we should be completely skeptical or not. Country Bears was one take, Mermaid, Villains and Zootopia will be our other bell-weather for their current show development capabilities.
Casper Gutman
Well-Known Member
At the risk of exposing my elitism (what a surprise!) guests are dumb. If you only build what guests think they want, you’ll ruin the parks - and guests will notice, although most won’t be able to articulate why they are less satisfied. Disneys restaurant menus are a great example of the destructive power of “catering to guests.” If Walt was preoccupied with giving consumers what they thought they wanted, he would never have made Snow White or Fantasia or built Disneyland.
The Leader of the Club
Well-Known Member
I mean, since 2017 WDW has gotten Pandora, RoTR, MMRR, Cosmic Rewind, Tron, and Rat. Your mileage may vary with these, but I think it’s a pretty stellar lineup.
I honestly think we need to have some optimism with changes to the parks, or we risk getting burnt out of this hobby we enjoy. I’m really upset that Muppets is closing, it’s my favorite attraction at WDW, but I’m not gonna let that taint my love of the rest of these parks. In the end of the day, it’s still a theme park. It’s a place where we go to forget about our troubles for a few days. If it stops being that, then maybe it’s time to find a new vacation spot.
JD80
Well-Known Member
Nothing is sacred in my eyes. I have my own personal favorites that would get me riled up but ultimately could say good bye to anything.
If I were in charge of the Parks and I had bonuses tied to operations and P&L the only way I keep things going 30+ years is if I make money off of merch/LL and the IP and the attractions maintains a high percentage of its theoretical capacity consistently over time and the cost of maintaining it is reasonable.
Incomudro
Well-Known Member
I think the "old" issue that Muppet 3D has/had is that 3D is ubiquitous now.
So making a big thing about it in the show really dates it.
What I liked best about the show is that it's a mix of film, animatronics, and a live character.
If they could have kept those elements, but updated the film so as not to act like 3D is new it would have worked better for me.