If Double Dumbo is not something really special, folks will argue that WDW would have been better off keeping Toon Town Fair the way it was. People will wonder if tearing down Mickey's house, Minnie's house, Donald's boat, and stripping all the themeing on the Barnstormer was really worth it in order to "double" dumbo.
Being a big Toontown fan, I have to agree. I think "Mickey's Toontown Circus" would have been a great way to "refresh" the area, add Dumbo, yet keep the Mouse Houses and Donald's Boat. The theme would just be changing from the Fair being in town to the Circus being in town, but it would still be Toontown. And if there were concerns that Dumbo didn't belong in a land with Fab Five characters - well, they are keeping Goofy around in the new land anyway!
I am not sure what people are expecting from the Great Goofini. I never rode the barnstormer (didn't go to WDW until 22 no need to visit toonfair) but it is a kids coaster. There will probably be some theming but what else can be expected with a children's coaster? If they were to be too heavy on the theming like some other parks (SF houston's old kiddie coaster was through the woods to make it feel mid-evil) then it would clutter the new area.
I have ridden Goofy's Barnstormer many, many times as I have 2 young children. The pathway underneath is the que line. According to the picture shown...the track looks almost identical except for the tower at the top of the lift hill...and also it looks like the plane now goes through a sign of some sort instead of the barn. This ride never had any real theming.
I thought the theming and backstory of Barnstormer was EXTREMELY well done, not just for a "kiddie coaster", but ANY coaster! The barn alone had great theming, props and backstory, including the AA chickens which humorously panicked every time the "Multiflex Octoplane" crashed through the barn. The concept of the "Multiflex Octoplane" crashing through the barn, and the Goofy-shaped outline of the crashed-in area, was ingenious and funny!
Then there was "Fearless Fido's Flight School" inside the barn, where cats and dogs could learn to fly, respresented by cute pictures of some of the dog and cat flight instructors.
You could also see the drafting table where Goofy designed his airplane, which had some clever gags about how the emergency escape parachute had been "cut for budgetary reasons", and showed Goofy stopping the plane by putting his feet through a hole in the floor for brakes!
Then, outside of the barn, along the queue path, there were the giant popcorn stalks, and the Goofy shaped scarecrow which didn't work very well, as a crow was sitting right on top of it! And the squashed squash. And the chicken coop turned into a makeshift radio station for WACKY Radio and its DJ, Red Barns - "the rowdiest rooster on radio"! (and you could hear this broadcast on the radio inside Minnie's House, as the stories found in the Toontown walkthroughs were all interconnected!)
And then there was the pair of pants that Goofy was using as a flag on the roof of the load building to measure the wind direction! And the jelly jar lights...
These are just a few examples of the numerous layers of detailed theming, gags, and backstory found in the Barnstormer barn and queue. And this was just the tip of the iceberg compared to the layers and layers of theming, gags, and backstory found in Mickey and Minnie's Houses. It's too bad that a lot of the Toontown haters (and I don't mean anyone in this thread, just in general) didn't take the time to enjoy these details when we had them, because they just thought of the area as a bunch of tents. And there will STILL be tents in the new area, anyway.
Following in the footsteps of Barnstormer, the "Goofini" will have a lot to live up to in the theming department.
Here's a few clips showcasing some of Barnstormer's theming:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PN4oGurx00s
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pknUGy5z510
And a few more clips illustrating and acknowledging the detailed theming of Toontown, including the Barnstormer:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5G5inzqY8BY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8zTcK-FKBb0