For us it's by far the worst attraction in all of their Disney Park. It's terribly dated, visually poor and the ride system is uncomfortable at best.
But, reach to their own I guess. I have no idea how anyone could say this is their favourite ride in all of Disney, but hey, everyone's different I guess.
Personally I think it needs knocking down and a new modern attraction putting in it's place...I think it’s one of the only attractions at WDW that has always been a walk on each and every time I've been to AK...which says it all.