Well, first of all, expecting the TDS ad first and finding the Celebrate ad made me cringe, if that doesn't say anything about it.
:lol:
Seriously, no competition. One pits stereotypical vignettes of American Lifestyle dropped against photo-altered images of IMPOSSIBLE things you can't do at the parks, such as eat a Birthday Cake with characters in a mysterious wooden hose, that from the looks of it, was somehow built like twelve feet away from Disneyland's Castle.
:brick:
Add in a Marketing Ploy, and drop in an 80's Training-Montage-Anthem and you have one jumbled ad appealing to the lowest demographic possible.
Take Tokyo's Ad. Not only do you have a beautifully-directed film, with a clear story, feeling, and tone, they ALSO manage to do it while showing off the beauty of the REAL park, no photo-trickery at all. And on top of everything, they even advertise the park's anniversary as a way to entice people to come back, or see what's new for the Celebration.
In short, one is a McDonald's ad, and one is practically a fine Short-Film that evokes real emotions, not just cupcake-and-balloon-do-right-by-your-six-year-old-wal-mart-emotions.