Very briefly, full reviews eventually --
Evil Dead was my #1. Great sets/costumes, endlessly creepy, talented casts, good mix of show scenes and scares.
Cabin and AWIL were both very solid houses but were overhyped significantly. I don't know why people are praising the latter as the second coming of Christ. The puppets are fantastic, but they aren't very scary after that first run... more just impressive. I dunno, I don't "get" it.
I wanted to love La Llorona more than I did. The masks in many of the scenes are flat out embarrassing. Felt too short, paled in comparison to Hollywood's effort, but taken on its own terms it's pretty good, just not great like I was hoping/expecting.
After those 4... we get into mediocrity to outright failures.
HAVOC was an absolute mess of design. The casts are very capable and doing the best with the little they have. It takes WAY too long to get to the "crash," which is where the actual scaring picks up.
Resident Evil was laughably terrible. As a friend put it, "the actors in there know they're in a $#!t house." Casts barely tried. Sets are generic and mostly reused from Silent Hill. More bland/unscary zombies, the few creatures either weren't scary or looked like rubber Spirit masks.
Afterlife somehow managed to be possibly the worst house I've ever done at HHN in my years of attendance despite having an amazing premise. The plot went off the rails pretty much immediately, the central concept was abandoned, there was no rhyme or reason to any sets, lame scares, a bored cast... just... terrible. Anyone who thought this compared to In-Between needs to get their head examined.
Streets were very uninteresting. The victim attacks were cool, as were the handful of photo ops (deer eater, barn, Michonne's pet, Bicycle Girl). Everything else was generic, repetitive, and very quickly not scary.
Bill & Ted may have been my favorite in my years of going. Surprisingly coherent plot, great character choices/casting, some hilarious jokes (lots of subtle stuff too), incredible choreography... it also helped I had VIP front row-center seating on two of my viewings. The Daft Punk robot twerked on me, it was glorious.